Advertisement
English transcript
If we could go out, away from the city lights,
to a dark sky, in a remote location on a moonless night and look up,
we would see untold number of stars.
Each star in the sky is a Sun,
and if our Sun has planets - Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, etc -
it seems natural to think that other stars should have planets also.
And they do.
Astronomers have found that each star in our sky
has at least one planet.
So, the next time you're out in the dark sky and look up,
you can start wondering about the planets around those other stars, other Suns.
We have identified thousands of planets around other stars.
Hundreds of them are about the size of Earth,
and dozens of them are expected to have surface temperatures
that are not too hot, not too cold, but just right for life.
I am here to tell you about how I and others
are going to be searching for signs of life
around these distant planets far away, orbiting other stars.
Now, we're not searching for radio signals
concocted by some kind of intelligent, little green people far away.
We are actually looking for a very, very, very subtle signal,
like a whiff of smoke,
that could be very hard to detect at all, and also very hard to interpret.
I'll start with Earth.
Earth is the only planet we know of that has life on it
in our Solar System and in the entire Universe,
and we start with a thought experiment:
could we detect life on Earth from afar
given instruments that we commonly use
to study planets and other astronomical objects?
The answer is "yes",
and Carl Sagan had a brilliant control experiment in 1990:
when the Galileo spacecraft was on its way to Jupiter,
it swung by Earth for gravity assist,
and he had the instruments turned on to look at Earth from far away,
and he had his team do like a blind setting,
pretending they knew nothing about Earth;
could they infer the presence of life on Earth?
And what they found were three things
that were strongly suggestive of life on Earth.
And I actually bechose their wording very carefully, as they might.
They didn't say, "Oh, we've absolutely found it",
it was "strongly suggestive".
Those 3 things were:
number one, abundant gaseous oxygen in the atmosphere.
We, as humans, breathe oxygen,
our atmosphere is filled to 20% volume by oxygen,
but actually - you know what? -
without life on Earth, without plants and photosynthetic bacteria
we would have virtually no oxygen.
Number two: they saw a widespread surface pigment
that corresponded to no-known molecule or mineral.
Number three: they observed abundant methane in the atmosphere
which in the presence of oxygen is in extreme thermodynamic disequilibrium.
And with these three things, they concluded
that there was strong evidence for life on Earth.
Here are some images from that experiment.
Basically, what they're saying is
that if you find a bunch of things that don't belong,
and you work hard to rule out every other possibility,
you may actually be left with the suggestion of finding life.
And that's what I and others are aiming to do for planets
far away around other stars.
So, let's zoom away from Earth,
pass the planets in our Solar System,
pass the human-made spacecraft to a distance of about 1,000 light years.
Now, this is actually a real map of real stars,
and the highlighted ones are stars with known planets.
We know of thousands of exoplanets around other stars.
And so, the question now is could we spot,
could we infer the presence of life on Earth
if we could have a space telescope, and look at the star far away,
and block out the starlight and see the planet directly.
And we are actually trying to build complicated space telescopes.
We are building them. We plan to launch them to do so.
So, the question is: could we see life from very far away?
And the answer is yes for an Earth twin,
and, in fact, we even know what Earth would look like from that far away.
It would look like this. This is a real image of Earth.
Not from a 1,000 light years away, but actually from four billion miles away
as taken by the Voyager 1 spacecraft some years ago.
Can you see Earth? Believe it or not, hat is Earth.
It's just amazing. It's a little tiny pale blue dot.
This here is light that is scattered in the camera -
the red band is light that is scattered in the camera optics,
but there's a pale blue dot.
I hope some of you are wondering
how on earth could we find life just from that little pale blue dot,
and in fact the reason Earth is blue in this image
it's not because of the oceans,
which actually are very dark in reflected light.
It's because the same is when our sky is blue.
It's light scattered off these small particles just makes this blue
it's actually called Rayleigh scattering.
So, what we would do is we'd need to analyze light in more detail
and let me explain that by this picture of a rainbow.
And here you see this light of the Sun is split up into many colors
by refraction in a raindrop.
Now, if we could look at the rainbow in more detail - in great detail -
we'd see some parts of the rainbow are missing,
not whole colors, but just, you know, thin lines would be missing,
and those are from gases in the Sun and in the Earth's atmosphere.
And here is a Solar spectrum;
that's a term for the Sun's light split up into colors,
and now you can clearly see the parts of the so-called rainbow that are missing.
And these are gases that are in the Sun's atmosphere
that have, I like to say, taken bites out of the spectrum.
They prevented some of the light from reaching the detector
and the instrument that made this measurement
because of the gases that just absorb light.
And so here you can see, if we could do a class on this,
and analyze a spectrum and learn all about -
you'd have to learn some quantum mechanics and about atoms and other things.
We could actually analyze this
and find out what is in the Sun's photosphere.
We're not going to do that now. Instead, we're going to go to
(Laughter)
Earth spectrum.
And here I'm showing you an image of Earth spectrum.
You can see at the bottom, a color green belt along the bottom,
and then you see a squiggly line.
We sometimes refer to this as squiggly line science.
But what it is, as you can see,
I want you to just see how some of the lines in the Solar spectrum
are very deep, very dark, perfectly dark.
That would correspond to a deep part here.
Some of them are more narrow.
So, there would be a narrow line like this.
Some you can see are shaded at the edges, and that's why it's sloped here.
If the Earth had no gases in the atmosphere,
this reflected light spectrum would be a straight line.
OK, it has various gases and I'm not going to go through what all of them are,
but this cartoon does highlight a few of the interesting ones.
It has - I'm just now repeating myself, but it has oxygen, it's this line here,
abundant gaseous oxygen that is made by life on Earth, and has a special here,
It's referred to as a vegetation jump, a special pigment.
It's not chlorophyll, but it's kind of related,
that on plants on Earth had a very strong rise in red,
with reflectivity.
We also have methane, atmospheric methane and other things also.
Water vapor - most of the big features in the Earth spectrum are from water vapor
and that is actually because water vapor
has very strong greenhouse gases, highly interactive with radiation.
And, actually, all life on Earth requires liquid water.
And so, when we look for another Earth,
when we are able to look at spectra of other planets,
we'd like to see water vapor in the atmosphere
as a sign of surface liquid water.
So, that's the Earth's twin, and this is real spectrum of Earth,
and that's how we're going to hope to find life in future.
But there is one thing here, and that is:
planets we have found so far,
we don't see them in a lot of detail like this image,
but we know they are very different from each other.
Planets come in all sizes, all masses, all of different orbits,
and we actually like to say in exoplanets
that anything is possible within the laws of physics and chemistry.
So, given that planets have such huge variety,
do you think that the first one we get to see
is going to look just like Earth?
So, that's my job as a professor or a scientist.
I think hard about problems,
and I'm trying to think through which molecules should it be,
how we are going to do this.
We're going to build a complicated space telescope,
and spend a lot of money; we want to know what we are looking for.
It's very hard to think that deeply, that outside of the box.
Sometimes when you're working very hard, take a little break, check your e-mail,
and almost every day, like many times a week,
when I check my e-mail, I get a crazy theory from someone.
I don't know if this happens to anybody here,
but someone has usually a very--
(Laughter)
about some new law of physics or their view of world.
So, please don't email me your crazy theory.
(Laughter)
I was working on this problem, and I started to realize that,
from my view, it seemed like any gas could conceivably be indicative of life
if it was produced in high enough quantities,
because life on Earth produces thousands of gases,
and thousands of gases, and which ones will, you know,
accumulate and exist in large quantities in an exoplanet, we don't know yet,
because the conditions could be very different,
life on those other planets may produce very different things,
and here on Earth much life produces gases for no apparent reason.
And so, with all that together, I came up with my own crazy theory,
and in this theory, I really thought that life produces also molecules.
Every small molecule that I could think of:
nitrogen, carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, carbon dioxide, oxygen,
you know, those are very small ones, but even bigger ones I could think of,
and I thought, "Wow, I can't believe this.
What if this theory is correct? What would it even mean?"
So, I recruited a couple of biochemistry colleagues,
we worked on this theory, and then what would I do?
I emailed professor--
- he's a Nobel laureate, actually, in the Physiology of Medicine -
and I said, "Can I come and tell you about my theory?"
And he actually knew me.
I wasn't just a random, you know, email writer, and he said, "OK."
So, I take my friends, and we go there, across the river to see him,
and immediately he said, "This is not right,"
and he pointed out a counterexample of a molecule
that's just not produced by life.
So we went back to the drawing board but we worked on it for another year,
and we found something pretty - I thought, something that appears to be very amazing
and that is life seems to produce nearly--
it produces a large fraction of molecules.
They're not all stand-alone molecules; that means they won't exist on their own,
but they appear to exist as substructures of other molecules.
And what my team found was that some of these
that are not produced by life fall into very distinct categories.
So, life seems to produce many molecules, just not all of them are stand-alone,
and the ones that life doesn't produce,
they actually may tell us something very useful
about the limits of terrestrial biochemistry,
and it may eventually have applications to toxicology
or even in pharmaceutical drug discovery.
That was a little aside,
to just give you a bit of flavor of working as a scientist on exoplanets.
But, back to exoplanets and atmospheres
- I'm just going to show you the list of what I started to do and what I work -
I literally wrote a computer code
to combine all the important biogenic elements
in any combination possible,
and we have got this huge, huge list.
It ended up being so long; I almost didn't know what to do about it.
But - (Laughter)
thanks to computer programming
and computers, and Python language especially,
we were able to make a lot of progress on this problem.
You can see some molecules,
and this is actually only a tiny amount of them
because some molecular formula,
there's no molecular structure that matches that formula.
Other formula,
there are many different incarnations depending on where the atoms are,
so you can get lots of them.
In the end, we almost have a list now, I think,
of 20 thousand molecules to work with,
and that's actually what I'm working on now -
it's how do we handle the fact
that life produces so many different molecules.
And on an exoplanet far away,
we don’t know yet which molecules could be the ones produced by life
that accumulate in the atmosphere.
I just wanted you to know that we're working on this,
and I have this cartoon to show you that we have thousands of molecules,
and we want to sort of filter them out: which ones are not likely to accumulate,
which ones would not have a spectroscopic line,
like the ones I showed you in the Solar spectrum,
which ones may also be produced by volcanoes.
So, we're working through this right now to see what is the possibility,
what we should be looking for.
So, I get the question all the time about why study exoplanets.
We have a lot of problems here.
And why are we doing this? Why should we care?
And one of my answers, from a scientist perspective, is well,
we have this natural curiosity about the world around us,
and we'd like to understand where did our Earth come from,
how did our Solar System form and evolve,
why is our planet, so far anyway, the only one with life?
But natural and scientific curiosity inevitably leads to breakthroughs
that were never anticipated, like the laser or GPS.
We didn't set out to make GPS so that we can all figure out how to navigate.
That came from a big history of people curious about building rockets
to us being able to launch spacecraft into low Earth orbit repeatedly,
and even the Hubble Space Telescope has many spinoff applications,
including medical imaging.
One of my favorite reasons for studying exoplanets
has to do with space engineering.
Exoplanets are so small and so faint,
and so less massive than their bright, adjacent host star
that all of the telescopes that we build and ones we’re working to
be able to find and identify another Earth
are very, very complicated.
And as a nation, we can't show the world what we can do in space,
through our defense technologies, which we keep hidden.
Instead, through civilian space science, we can showcase our technical prowess.
And it's not only that, but this sort of ability to define, think about, and solve
very big, complex, scientific and technological problems
is what we need to be doing to maintain our technological leadership
and to train the next generation and inspire them.
But for me, my real reason for studying exoplanets
is just one of exploration.
And here now, we're zooming out away from 1,000 light years,
out to what we think our Milky Way galaxy looks like
with hundreds of billions of stars and highlighted are just the planets,
the stars with planets we know about already,
and this is our frontier.
For me it's a journey of exploration.
We dream big because we can,
and we explore because that's part of what it means to be human.
Thank you for your attention.
(Applause)
to a dark sky, in a remote location on a moonless night and look up,
we would see untold number of stars.
Each star in the sky is a Sun,
and if our Sun has planets - Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, etc -
it seems natural to think that other stars should have planets also.
And they do.
Astronomers have found that each star in our sky
has at least one planet.
So, the next time you're out in the dark sky and look up,
you can start wondering about the planets around those other stars, other Suns.
We have identified thousands of planets around other stars.
Hundreds of them are about the size of Earth,
and dozens of them are expected to have surface temperatures
that are not too hot, not too cold, but just right for life.
I am here to tell you about how I and others
are going to be searching for signs of life
around these distant planets far away, orbiting other stars.
Now, we're not searching for radio signals
concocted by some kind of intelligent, little green people far away.
We are actually looking for a very, very, very subtle signal,
like a whiff of smoke,
that could be very hard to detect at all, and also very hard to interpret.
I'll start with Earth.
Earth is the only planet we know of that has life on it
in our Solar System and in the entire Universe,
and we start with a thought experiment:
could we detect life on Earth from afar
given instruments that we commonly use
to study planets and other astronomical objects?
The answer is "yes",
and Carl Sagan had a brilliant control experiment in 1990:
when the Galileo spacecraft was on its way to Jupiter,
it swung by Earth for gravity assist,
and he had the instruments turned on to look at Earth from far away,
and he had his team do like a blind setting,
pretending they knew nothing about Earth;
could they infer the presence of life on Earth?
And what they found were three things
that were strongly suggestive of life on Earth.
And I actually bechose their wording very carefully, as they might.
They didn't say, "Oh, we've absolutely found it",
it was "strongly suggestive".
Those 3 things were:
number one, abundant gaseous oxygen in the atmosphere.
We, as humans, breathe oxygen,
our atmosphere is filled to 20% volume by oxygen,
but actually - you know what? -
without life on Earth, without plants and photosynthetic bacteria
we would have virtually no oxygen.
Number two: they saw a widespread surface pigment
that corresponded to no-known molecule or mineral.
Number three: they observed abundant methane in the atmosphere
which in the presence of oxygen is in extreme thermodynamic disequilibrium.
And with these three things, they concluded
that there was strong evidence for life on Earth.
Here are some images from that experiment.
Basically, what they're saying is
that if you find a bunch of things that don't belong,
and you work hard to rule out every other possibility,
you may actually be left with the suggestion of finding life.
And that's what I and others are aiming to do for planets
far away around other stars.
So, let's zoom away from Earth,
pass the planets in our Solar System,
pass the human-made spacecraft to a distance of about 1,000 light years.
Now, this is actually a real map of real stars,
and the highlighted ones are stars with known planets.
We know of thousands of exoplanets around other stars.
And so, the question now is could we spot,
could we infer the presence of life on Earth
if we could have a space telescope, and look at the star far away,
and block out the starlight and see the planet directly.
And we are actually trying to build complicated space telescopes.
We are building them. We plan to launch them to do so.
So, the question is: could we see life from very far away?
And the answer is yes for an Earth twin,
and, in fact, we even know what Earth would look like from that far away.
It would look like this. This is a real image of Earth.
Not from a 1,000 light years away, but actually from four billion miles away
as taken by the Voyager 1 spacecraft some years ago.
Can you see Earth? Believe it or not, hat is Earth.
It's just amazing. It's a little tiny pale blue dot.
This here is light that is scattered in the camera -
the red band is light that is scattered in the camera optics,
but there's a pale blue dot.
I hope some of you are wondering
how on earth could we find life just from that little pale blue dot,
and in fact the reason Earth is blue in this image
it's not because of the oceans,
which actually are very dark in reflected light.
It's because the same is when our sky is blue.
It's light scattered off these small particles just makes this blue
it's actually called Rayleigh scattering.
So, what we would do is we'd need to analyze light in more detail
and let me explain that by this picture of a rainbow.
And here you see this light of the Sun is split up into many colors
by refraction in a raindrop.
Now, if we could look at the rainbow in more detail - in great detail -
we'd see some parts of the rainbow are missing,
not whole colors, but just, you know, thin lines would be missing,
and those are from gases in the Sun and in the Earth's atmosphere.
And here is a Solar spectrum;
that's a term for the Sun's light split up into colors,
and now you can clearly see the parts of the so-called rainbow that are missing.
And these are gases that are in the Sun's atmosphere
that have, I like to say, taken bites out of the spectrum.
They prevented some of the light from reaching the detector
and the instrument that made this measurement
because of the gases that just absorb light.
And so here you can see, if we could do a class on this,
and analyze a spectrum and learn all about -
you'd have to learn some quantum mechanics and about atoms and other things.
We could actually analyze this
and find out what is in the Sun's photosphere.
We're not going to do that now. Instead, we're going to go to
(Laughter)
Earth spectrum.
And here I'm showing you an image of Earth spectrum.
You can see at the bottom, a color green belt along the bottom,
and then you see a squiggly line.
We sometimes refer to this as squiggly line science.
But what it is, as you can see,
I want you to just see how some of the lines in the Solar spectrum
are very deep, very dark, perfectly dark.
That would correspond to a deep part here.
Some of them are more narrow.
So, there would be a narrow line like this.
Some you can see are shaded at the edges, and that's why it's sloped here.
If the Earth had no gases in the atmosphere,
this reflected light spectrum would be a straight line.
OK, it has various gases and I'm not going to go through what all of them are,
but this cartoon does highlight a few of the interesting ones.
It has - I'm just now repeating myself, but it has oxygen, it's this line here,
abundant gaseous oxygen that is made by life on Earth, and has a special here,
It's referred to as a vegetation jump, a special pigment.
It's not chlorophyll, but it's kind of related,
that on plants on Earth had a very strong rise in red,
with reflectivity.
We also have methane, atmospheric methane and other things also.
Water vapor - most of the big features in the Earth spectrum are from water vapor
and that is actually because water vapor
has very strong greenhouse gases, highly interactive with radiation.
And, actually, all life on Earth requires liquid water.
And so, when we look for another Earth,
when we are able to look at spectra of other planets,
we'd like to see water vapor in the atmosphere
as a sign of surface liquid water.
So, that's the Earth's twin, and this is real spectrum of Earth,
and that's how we're going to hope to find life in future.
But there is one thing here, and that is:
planets we have found so far,
we don't see them in a lot of detail like this image,
but we know they are very different from each other.
Planets come in all sizes, all masses, all of different orbits,
and we actually like to say in exoplanets
that anything is possible within the laws of physics and chemistry.
So, given that planets have such huge variety,
do you think that the first one we get to see
is going to look just like Earth?
So, that's my job as a professor or a scientist.
I think hard about problems,
and I'm trying to think through which molecules should it be,
how we are going to do this.
We're going to build a complicated space telescope,
and spend a lot of money; we want to know what we are looking for.
It's very hard to think that deeply, that outside of the box.
Sometimes when you're working very hard, take a little break, check your e-mail,
and almost every day, like many times a week,
when I check my e-mail, I get a crazy theory from someone.
I don't know if this happens to anybody here,
but someone has usually a very--
(Laughter)
about some new law of physics or their view of world.
So, please don't email me your crazy theory.
(Laughter)
I was working on this problem, and I started to realize that,
from my view, it seemed like any gas could conceivably be indicative of life
if it was produced in high enough quantities,
because life on Earth produces thousands of gases,
and thousands of gases, and which ones will, you know,
accumulate and exist in large quantities in an exoplanet, we don't know yet,
because the conditions could be very different,
life on those other planets may produce very different things,
and here on Earth much life produces gases for no apparent reason.
And so, with all that together, I came up with my own crazy theory,
and in this theory, I really thought that life produces also molecules.
Every small molecule that I could think of:
nitrogen, carbon dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, carbon dioxide, oxygen,
you know, those are very small ones, but even bigger ones I could think of,
and I thought, "Wow, I can't believe this.
What if this theory is correct? What would it even mean?"
So, I recruited a couple of biochemistry colleagues,
we worked on this theory, and then what would I do?
I emailed professor--
- he's a Nobel laureate, actually, in the Physiology of Medicine -
and I said, "Can I come and tell you about my theory?"
And he actually knew me.
I wasn't just a random, you know, email writer, and he said, "OK."
So, I take my friends, and we go there, across the river to see him,
and immediately he said, "This is not right,"
and he pointed out a counterexample of a molecule
that's just not produced by life.
So we went back to the drawing board but we worked on it for another year,
and we found something pretty - I thought, something that appears to be very amazing
and that is life seems to produce nearly--
it produces a large fraction of molecules.
They're not all stand-alone molecules; that means they won't exist on their own,
but they appear to exist as substructures of other molecules.
And what my team found was that some of these
that are not produced by life fall into very distinct categories.
So, life seems to produce many molecules, just not all of them are stand-alone,
and the ones that life doesn't produce,
they actually may tell us something very useful
about the limits of terrestrial biochemistry,
and it may eventually have applications to toxicology
or even in pharmaceutical drug discovery.
That was a little aside,
to just give you a bit of flavor of working as a scientist on exoplanets.
But, back to exoplanets and atmospheres
- I'm just going to show you the list of what I started to do and what I work -
I literally wrote a computer code
to combine all the important biogenic elements
in any combination possible,
and we have got this huge, huge list.
It ended up being so long; I almost didn't know what to do about it.
But - (Laughter)
thanks to computer programming
and computers, and Python language especially,
we were able to make a lot of progress on this problem.
You can see some molecules,
and this is actually only a tiny amount of them
because some molecular formula,
there's no molecular structure that matches that formula.
Other formula,
there are many different incarnations depending on where the atoms are,
so you can get lots of them.
In the end, we almost have a list now, I think,
of 20 thousand molecules to work with,
and that's actually what I'm working on now -
it's how do we handle the fact
that life produces so many different molecules.
And on an exoplanet far away,
we don’t know yet which molecules could be the ones produced by life
that accumulate in the atmosphere.
I just wanted you to know that we're working on this,
and I have this cartoon to show you that we have thousands of molecules,
and we want to sort of filter them out: which ones are not likely to accumulate,
which ones would not have a spectroscopic line,
like the ones I showed you in the Solar spectrum,
which ones may also be produced by volcanoes.
So, we're working through this right now to see what is the possibility,
what we should be looking for.
So, I get the question all the time about why study exoplanets.
We have a lot of problems here.
And why are we doing this? Why should we care?
And one of my answers, from a scientist perspective, is well,
we have this natural curiosity about the world around us,
and we'd like to understand where did our Earth come from,
how did our Solar System form and evolve,
why is our planet, so far anyway, the only one with life?
But natural and scientific curiosity inevitably leads to breakthroughs
that were never anticipated, like the laser or GPS.
We didn't set out to make GPS so that we can all figure out how to navigate.
That came from a big history of people curious about building rockets
to us being able to launch spacecraft into low Earth orbit repeatedly,
and even the Hubble Space Telescope has many spinoff applications,
including medical imaging.
One of my favorite reasons for studying exoplanets
has to do with space engineering.
Exoplanets are so small and so faint,
and so less massive than their bright, adjacent host star
that all of the telescopes that we build and ones we’re working to
be able to find and identify another Earth
are very, very complicated.
And as a nation, we can't show the world what we can do in space,
through our defense technologies, which we keep hidden.
Instead, through civilian space science, we can showcase our technical prowess.
And it's not only that, but this sort of ability to define, think about, and solve
very big, complex, scientific and technological problems
is what we need to be doing to maintain our technological leadership
and to train the next generation and inspire them.
But for me, my real reason for studying exoplanets
is just one of exploration.
And here now, we're zooming out away from 1,000 light years,
out to what we think our Milky Way galaxy looks like
with hundreds of billions of stars and highlighted are just the planets,
the stars with planets we know about already,
and this is our frontier.
For me it's a journey of exploration.
We dream big because we can,
and we explore because that's part of what it means to be human.
Thank you for your attention.
(Applause)