YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 1,126 lines · added Dec 6, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Prof: We're discussing the fertility transition and
we've talked that prior to the fertility transition there was
control of fertility, but it was at a very high level.
In different parts of the world we talked in very general terms
about it.
I want to just describe a little bit about what the story
was in Europe, exactly how fertility was
controlled.
One of the main reasons, I mentioned this before,
but didn't really describe it, is control of marriage.
That the number of people that were allowed to,
and in some sense, get married changed with
economic conditions and agricultural conditions.
You can see that very clearly wherever you get statistics from
the period.
As you know, the first year of the Black
Death was 1347-1348, and huge numbers of people died
and their land was immediately taken over by someone else.
Immediately these new landowners got married.
There was an enormous burst of marriage.
Like in one small French village there had been 10 to 12
marriages a year in the preceding decade.
In 1349, the first year after that phase of the plague passed
it went from 10 to 12, to 86 marriages,
an enormous thing.
What was going on is there was--before the Black Death when
Europe was crowded for its system there was a huge pool of
unmarried individuals who really wanted to get married,
but did not have any land on which to support themselves or a
family and the opening of the land allows marriage to take
place.
Then not only did they get married right away,
but the women got pregnant immediately,
and one contemporary observer wrote,
"There are pregnant women wherever you look."
This is 1349.
Up--this fertility rate was a flexible system that moved up
and down according to economic and demographic conditions.
In England, there's data from the 1550s and later,
the gross reproduction rate, that's the number of women--
there are a certain number of women in one generation how many
female children do they produce?
In the 1550s it was 2.8, so one will reproduce a woman,
the gross reproduction rate will be one, but they were
producing 2.8.
A century later it drops down to 1.8 and that's the 1650s,
and by 1880s it rises again to over three,
so there's enormous range between one,
close to one, less than two,
just reproducing themselves getting into this dangerous
thing where-- with the very high death rates,
where the whole society at that rate won't continue--
and a factor of three women which will do just fine.
You can see the same thing at the age of marriage,
not only the numbers of marriage of course but the age
of marriage.
During the early 1800s remember that was a time when the
American food is there, European population was rising,
strong as a high birth rate so land hunger became--
land--there was no extra land available so marriage became
later and later, and eventually reached 23 to 28
for females and even older than that for males.
By that time probably the average lifespan was 35,
it had improved some, but if you're fertile at say 15
and you don't marry until 28, that's a huge chunk of your
reproductive life where you're not reproducing,
that reduces the birth rate and keeps the population in check.
However, once in marriage, the children just flowed.
There was no--apparently no control within marriage
whatsoever.
In 300 years--all the data that we have says that in 300 years
in Europe there was no control of fertility within marriage,
all the control, all the social control of
population was in how many people got married,
what they called the nuptiality; the fraction of people that got
married was the total mechanism of social control.
There's of course external control by disease,
by famines because some plague of the plants,
and then there were individual controls which we've talked
about infanticide and so forth.
In terms of social controls, the northwestern--
the Northern Europeans, especially northwestern
European model was controlled marriage and it was quite
effective.
These marriage controls didn't just happen automatically,
people just didn't sort of have a rational sense that said,
'Oh I can't get married.'
There was really--the controls were forced upon them.
Most land was owned by some landowner and the man was given
a plot of land which he could work.
It was the size so that one individual could work this plot
of land.
He starts having children.
Well the landlord knows that only one son is needed to farm
that land, and the father knows he can
only give that land to one son, so there's tremendous pressure
if you have extra children they can't stay at home.
You'll see when we talk about China a very different model.
He can't stay at home, those people are forced off to
the cities, and in the cities are very
dangerous and disease ridden places,
so they just die in the cities, and the cities are growing this
time but very high death rates still in the cities.
About one-third, each generation had to be
replenished as I've mentioned to you, but about one-third in the
cities.
The landlord of course didn't want these extra children around
because he would have more and more people to feed with the
same amount of land therefore the same amount of production.
You had to get the landlord's permission in order to get
married and if you didn't--if he didn't have extra land for you,
you couldn't get married.
Of course officially it wasn't the landlord but it was the
local parish church that you had to get married in,
but guess who hired the parish minister or priest?
The local landlord, and the whole structure of
churches almost everywhere is that they are very much either
controlled by or mutual support of the gentry,
the rich people and the religious authorities intermix.
They weren't allowed to get married either by the landlord
or by the church.
It was very--you had to post what they called banns so
everybody knew there was a marriage,
and of course the landlord would notice,
and so it was impossible to do anything about that.
Another mechanism was going off and becoming a servant that was
one of the very standard kinds of things.
They would leave home very young become a servant and--
males and females both servants in the houses,
you've all seen these Victorian movies and earlier movies,
how many servants they have.
Of course they were never allowed to get married,
not allowed to have sex, no boyfriend,
no girlfriend, none of that was allowed--
very, very strict rules on house servants and house
servants were a very large faction of the young people--
of everybody in, say, England.
Then those that didn't become servants would go off and become
an apprentice.
One son stays at home, the others go off and become
apprentices, and apprenticeship was a very
long period of time in which they had to learn the skills and
get some sort of resources so that they could buy the
equipment and rent the shop and set up eventually on their own,
or wait until the master died and then inherit the master's
place.
The end result of all this is that it took many,
many years to establish a sufficient economic base so that
the society would allow you to get married.
Many people never got married; I'll show you a little bit
later what the marriage rates actually were in Europe during
this period, and its surprisingly low.
The culture adapts to this.
What do all these unmarried men and women do?
We have the spinster woman; we have the confirmed bachelor,
again you've seen men in much British comedy and British
movies about-- always has characters in it
where some confirmed bachelor, he's just not getting married.
Presumably a fair amount of the homosexuality that was present,
especially in the British upper classes is due to this whole
tradition that a lot of males are not going to get married,
and then they do something with their sexual impulse.
Of course that's not proven; we don't really understand the
basis of homosexuality.
Females were also, like the males,
forced off the land, if they were not the wife of
the one son that inherited the land,
they had to go somewhere else so they went to the cities where
there were not jobs, especially not jobs for women
so they become sort of a floating population,
very largely prostitutes--huge explosion of prostitution at
this time both because of the excess women that are trying to
stay alive that have migrated into the cities,
and there's all these bachelors there having some sort of job
that could pay for their services.
Of course you know that babies that resulted from any of these
situations were very often just abandoned and left to die.
This control of marriage, that marriage was the control,
the social control on population lasted well into the
1800s, well into and possibly even
through the Victorian era.
These mechanisms together reduced the north European
birthrate, and especially in England, to about 50% of what it
otherwise could have been.
Remember we did calculations of how many children one can have,
and then there's always examples much to the high end of
that.
But in England taking a reasonable number,
these controls of marriage cut the birthrate in half.
What did it feel like to the people involved in this?
I suspect a fair number of you have heard this quote.
It's a letter from a woman to her uncle.
Don't shout out but raise your hand if you know it.
"I think dearest uncle that you cannot really wish me
to be the mother of a numerous family,
for I think you will see the great inconvenience in a large
family would be the hardship to myself.
Men never think what a hard task it is for us women to go
through this pregnancy very often."
Have you heard this?
No, no one's heard this letter, it's very famous.
This is a woman in this situation.
She's married, and therefore she's having
children one after the other with no kind of control,
and she's complaining, 'this is hard on me and why
don't you men ever think how hard this is on me?'
What social class, is this a poor woman,
middle class woman, upper class woman?
Having all this--no ideas; it's Queen Victoria.
Here's by far the richest woman in the world,
has all the help, all the money,
all the food, and, even for her,
it's a burden and she probably doesn't have to do much of the
burden except handle the pregnancy and childbearing,
and if she perceives it as a burden,
then can you imagine what the common woman thinks of it.
By the way, it's Queen Victoria to her uncle who is King Leopold
of Belgium, you've heard this before.
When sexuality itself since--a lot of problems with sexuality
at that time.
You've been reading some stuff about it,
and one of the things is that men, aside from the childbirth
aspect of it that women were of course always worried that if
they had sex they would get pregnant and often they didn't--
usually they did not want to get pregnant,
but also the men were not very skilled.
They either did not know how to pleasure a woman,
they didn't want to, or they thought it was very
improper to even try to pleasure a woman.
Here's another quote from Lady Alice Huntington--
Hillingdon--1857, she died only in 1940 so we're
really coming up to fairly recent kinds of times,
and presumably, this was written in her journal
in 1912.
No one can find that journal so they don't know the state of--
how apocryphal this is, but this is a quote that again
you've probably heard, at least part of it.
"I am happy now that George,"
her husband, "calls on my bedchamber
less frequently then of old.
As it is, I now endure but two calls a week and,
when I hear his steps outside my door,
I lie down upon my bed, close my eyes,
open my legs and think of England."
Sometimes the quote is, "think of Victoria,"
but apparently think of England is the proper--
again we're not talking about some poor woman with a brutal
husband, as in some Oliver Twist movies,
this is a very high status lady.
How did this change and who was arrayed against this?
People, women especially, were not happy with the
situation.
Young men of course wanted to get married,
couldn't until they were old, and we've talked about that
situation in Africa where the bride price is very high,
the old men control the bride price,
they don't allow the young men to get married until there's
almost a revolution.
This is an aside, but with respect to the bride
price, we hear a lot about older men marrying or having sex with
younger women.
In the West it's one of the things we sort of complain
about, about other cultures that this
great disparity in age-- an older man with a younger
woman.
We tend to blame the man who's getting married,
but if you think of it from the point of view of their society,
that man has been under the control of even older guys,
the really powerful guys, and so he's been abused and not
allowed to get married until he's old.
The women of his age are already married to the much
older guys so this is his only option.
Again, within a society these things all intermingle and form
a pattern, not necessarily a good pattern,
not necessarily a pattern that the people like,
but it is a tight web.
Coming back to Europe, there was this unfortunate
situation where young men weren't allowed to get married,
young women weren't allowed to get married,
once you're in marriage the sexual mores were so straight
jacketed that it was not pleasurable for most of the
women apparently, and who knows what the men were
using, the Victorian pornography
during this period is lots of mistresses,
lots of prostitution and lots of being whipped.
They loved to get punished themselves, which is a
surprising preponderance of masochistic sexuality in the
Victorian literature of that time.
At least from our point of view, sexuality was a mess.
So some people tried to change this,
of course there's always pioneers, and in England one of
the pioneers was a man and a woman,
Charles Bradlaugh and Annie Besant.
In 1877 family planning was--contraception was coming
into possibility in England and so they distributed--
printed and distributed what we would now consider a very mild
pamphlet about birth control called,
The Fruits of Philosophy.
It was very abstract and philosophical.
Of course what happened to them?
Arrested, indicted, and the official indictment
accused them of 'inciting and encouraging the subjects of the
Queen to indecent, obscene, unnatural,
and immoral practices, and to bring them,' the
citizens of the Queen, the subjects of the Queen,
'to a state of wickedness, lewdness, and debauchery.'
This is because they were saying that--well there's these
things called condoms around and why don't you use them.
This trial was very interesting in that in a culture there's
certain things you can't talk about.
If something is culturally forbidden, like almost anything
to do with sex in marriage, you just couldn't talk about
it.
Now here's this big trial in London, very famous,
all the newspapers are carrying it, and guess what everybody
learns about?
Birth control; and a very big thing and some
scholars, some historians
attribute--there's just the period when the use of birth
control is increasing tremendously in England,
-- and that this trial popularized it.
What did we have something similar a few years ago in
America with our President?
Bill Clinton and oral sex, are you all too young to--
that was a taboo topic, you could not discuss it and
then the right wing, the conservatives who were
opposed to this kind of free sexual activity publicized it
and publicized, and publicized it until every
teenager in America knew about oral sex and now the data is
that oral sex has just gone exponentially down into the high
schools and even junior high schools.
I could tell you stories about that, but I won't.
With all this moralizing about it that the religious leaders,
the political leaders, the medical doctors said it was
bad for you, you've read some of that in
your reading, everybody is--they were
terrorized in a sense.
There was an intellectual terrorization of the people,
they feared legal prosecution.
Most of these things were illegal, to buy things,
to use things, to write about them,
to publish them.
They were told that they would get physical injury.
You may have heard that masturbation will make you blind
and that--I don't know if any of your parents said that but I
heard it in my time.
Mental injury, if it doesn't make you blind,
it'll make you crazy, and deep moral reservations and
just straight aesthetic distaste that when the society frowns on
something we sort of have incorporated a kind of revulsion
to anything which society considers disgusting,
and contraceptives themselves were considered repulsive,
unnatural, only for prostitutes, that kind of thing.
Of course, at that time, almost--a lot of people were
starting to do it, but since you couldn't talk
about it publicly, no one knew what everyone else
was doing so they thought they had to take this great leap
themselves in defiance of everything that their culture is
telling them.
How did it--what happened an individual's starting to think
about these things.
We have some interesting--a lot of interesting stuff referred to
in the reading.
Some of this in your reading is letters to various pioneers,
Margaret Sanger or who was it in England the--
I'm blocking on the name of the clinic in England .
We have letters from women sort of begging information on how to
keep from getting pregnant again.
A lot of it is not with any official organizations,
just women talking to women, and some of it can be relaxed
at a little bit later stage.
There's a series of nice interviews from the 1920s and
1930s with elderly Italian and Jewish women in the United
States.
They talked to each other about technique,
because techniques is one of the things,
and this interview is from an Italian American woman born in
the U.S.
in 1920, recent immigrant parents, and the conversation
took place in the late 1930s.
She works in a hair dressing salon and she gets engaged,
and of course all her coworkers know about it,
and so an interviewer--an anthropologist--
a sociologist--goes in and starts asking her about it.
Apparently prior to this little quote they had brought up the
topic of birth control so the interviewer says,
"How did you learn about condoms?"
Nina: "One of my customers said, 'I really hope you don't
get pregnant, let him wear a raincoat.'
So I started wondering, I'm thinking,
I'm working and my mind just can't work out what a raincoat
is."
Then Mary White who worked for me said, "Baby what's on
your mind?
I said, "Mrs. Jacobs said a funny thing to me,
she said my ring was lovely,"
her marriage ring, "but she hoped I didn't
start a family and he should wear a raincoat.
But I can't ask Johnny to wear a raincoat to bed."
This Mary White laughed and laughed and says,
"She means he's to wear a condom."
"What is it?"
Nina said.
And then she got told and got enlightened in this and it's
that kind of conversation where individual people of not very
high class are learning that it's okay to buck the trend and
even the basic information they previously don't have.
It doesn't always work out that, when these discussions
take place, that the participants do take
on the new behavior, sometimes they don't want to do
that.
Gossip--most conversation by humans is gossip and there's
very good studies showing this.
We know that from our chimps days we're a very social
species, that status is so terribly
important and status translates to social acceptability,
so the purpose of gossip is to find out what the limits of
social acceptability are.
Gossip is almost exclusively about someone who has stepped
over what was perceived to be the limit and either gotten away
with it or not gotten away with it,
or something that's now just inside the limit.
A large fraction of gossip is to see what is socially
acceptable in my circle, and sometimes like we've seen
here, the use of condoms becomes
socially acceptable as a result of discussions like this.
Sometimes it--at least this individual at this time it
doesn't become acceptable.
Where is this other quote that I'm lookin
…

Need subtitles from another video?