Advertisement
English transcript
Concerned that its citizens may be under terrorist threat, Senegal is considering a nationwide
ban on burqas and niqabs in public spaces. If the ban is enacted, some will likely tout
this as a victory in strengthening security; while, others might see this ban as a discriminatory
measure that infringes upon religious freedom. A huge part of the debate centers around how
to achieve proper identification of an individual, if the face is covered. So how do different
countries deal with the issue of religious headdresses in identification procedures?
Well, for countries with national bans, the answer is clear: face coverings are simply
not allowed. And it’s important to note that should it succeed, Senegal would not
be the first country to enact a nationwide ban on full-face veils, like burqas and niqabs.
The Muslim majority country would join France, Belgium, The Republic of Congo, and Chad in
what seems to be a growing trend in banning burqas and niqabs in public spaces. In these
countries, it is unequivocally clear that covering one’s face in public, under any
circumstances, is prohibited. The most prominent argument behind these bans tends to be that
preventing the face from being seen poses a security threat. Chad decided to do so after
suicide bombers - both men and women - disguised themselves in full-faced veils and launched
attacks that killed dozens of people in June 2015. And similar attacks in Nigeria and Cameroon
prompted other countries to reassess their own policies. Some believe nationwide bans
save lives. This is also usually the reasoning behind bans at the local level. For example,
in Germany about half of its states prohibit school teachers from covering their faces.
And in Tunisia and the Netherlands, the law prohibits full-face coverings in government
buildings and schools.” But other countries tend to have more nuanced approaches, banning
full-face veils only when deemed obstructive or dangerous. And in many countries, women
are free to wear what they like unless they are being stopped by police or applying for
passports or driver's licenses. When being stopped by an authority, some accommodate
by having a female officer ID the suspect - since in Islam a woman is not required to
cover her face in front of other women. In the United States, all people are required
to show their faces for passports and drivers’ licenses. And, though this rule has been contested
by some as a violation of religious expression, the government’s stance is that “The requirement
that all potential drivers have their driver's licence photos taken unveiled, uncloaked,
and unmasked does not unconstitutionally burden the free exercise of religion.” Britain
takes a similar approach. After documenting cases of women allegedly cheating on their
drivers’ tests by having relatives impersonate them, the Driving Standards Agency prohibited
the full veil. However, on the other side of the spectrum is Saudi Arabia, which requires
women to fully cover themselves in public spaces. While it is currently the only country
that mandates full-face coverings, we should note that in other countries cultural norms
encourage it. In Iran, a hijab is required by law, but this veil only covers the hair.
Still, both Iran and Saudi Arabia have Morality or religious police, which can issue fines
or stop uncovered women. we should note that in other countries cultural norms encourage
it. So how does Saudi Arabia deal with identifying women? Well, it’s a bit unclear. Though
if we take cues from some reports, police may compare a woman’s ID to other documents
she may be carrying in order to identify her. Or may take the word of their male chaperones,
as was the case before 2013 when women were not required to carry IDs... Along these lines,
some argue that the security threat lies in what might be hidden underneath a burqa or
long loose clothing - and so revealing the face is often unnecessary - they argue that
a metal detector would be more effective in ensuring safety. But, for more on understanding
the role of religious headdresses and how effective they are at protecting women from
harassment, click here now.
Thanks for watching. Remember to Subscribe.
ban on burqas and niqabs in public spaces. If the ban is enacted, some will likely tout
this as a victory in strengthening security; while, others might see this ban as a discriminatory
measure that infringes upon religious freedom. A huge part of the debate centers around how
to achieve proper identification of an individual, if the face is covered. So how do different
countries deal with the issue of religious headdresses in identification procedures?
Well, for countries with national bans, the answer is clear: face coverings are simply
not allowed. And it’s important to note that should it succeed, Senegal would not
be the first country to enact a nationwide ban on full-face veils, like burqas and niqabs.
The Muslim majority country would join France, Belgium, The Republic of Congo, and Chad in
what seems to be a growing trend in banning burqas and niqabs in public spaces. In these
countries, it is unequivocally clear that covering one’s face in public, under any
circumstances, is prohibited. The most prominent argument behind these bans tends to be that
preventing the face from being seen poses a security threat. Chad decided to do so after
suicide bombers - both men and women - disguised themselves in full-faced veils and launched
attacks that killed dozens of people in June 2015. And similar attacks in Nigeria and Cameroon
prompted other countries to reassess their own policies. Some believe nationwide bans
save lives. This is also usually the reasoning behind bans at the local level. For example,
in Germany about half of its states prohibit school teachers from covering their faces.
And in Tunisia and the Netherlands, the law prohibits full-face coverings in government
buildings and schools.” But other countries tend to have more nuanced approaches, banning
full-face veils only when deemed obstructive or dangerous. And in many countries, women
are free to wear what they like unless they are being stopped by police or applying for
passports or driver's licenses. When being stopped by an authority, some accommodate
by having a female officer ID the suspect - since in Islam a woman is not required to
cover her face in front of other women. In the United States, all people are required
to show their faces for passports and drivers’ licenses. And, though this rule has been contested
by some as a violation of religious expression, the government’s stance is that “The requirement
that all potential drivers have their driver's licence photos taken unveiled, uncloaked,
and unmasked does not unconstitutionally burden the free exercise of religion.” Britain
takes a similar approach. After documenting cases of women allegedly cheating on their
drivers’ tests by having relatives impersonate them, the Driving Standards Agency prohibited
the full veil. However, on the other side of the spectrum is Saudi Arabia, which requires
women to fully cover themselves in public spaces. While it is currently the only country
that mandates full-face coverings, we should note that in other countries cultural norms
encourage it. In Iran, a hijab is required by law, but this veil only covers the hair.
Still, both Iran and Saudi Arabia have Morality or religious police, which can issue fines
or stop uncovered women. we should note that in other countries cultural norms encourage
it. So how does Saudi Arabia deal with identifying women? Well, it’s a bit unclear. Though
if we take cues from some reports, police may compare a woman’s ID to other documents
she may be carrying in order to identify her. Or may take the word of their male chaperones,
as was the case before 2013 when women were not required to carry IDs... Along these lines,
some argue that the security threat lies in what might be hidden underneath a burqa or
long loose clothing - and so revealing the face is often unnecessary - they argue that
a metal detector would be more effective in ensuring safety. But, for more on understanding
the role of religious headdresses and how effective they are at protecting women from
harassment, click here now.
Thanks for watching. Remember to Subscribe.