Advertisement
English transcript
In an unprecedented move, members of The United Nations have provided written suggestions
with respect to the structure of the UN Security Council, a group of 15 countries in charge
of identifying threats to peace and determining the appropriate course of action. Recently,
India has brought up concerns that many nations, including themselves and countries within
Africa, are not being fairly represented. So, it got us wondering, how does the UN Security
Council work and why are so many countries upset with the way it’s run? Well, The United
Nations as a whole was established after World War II with 51 founding countries on board
- though today 193 countries participate. Its aim is to maintain peace and security.
It has developed multiple programs and 6 main governing bodies in areas like economics,
human rights, and social policy. But, arguably one of the most contentious parts of the UN
is The UN Security Council. The contention stems largely from the council’s power,
structure, and effectiveness. In terms of power, it is the only body in the UN that
can issue binding resolutions to other states. If the 15 member council passes a substantive
resolution, all 193 member, are obligated to follow through. As you can imagine, member
states at large do not always agree with the council, which has led to some instances of
dissent. What makes these resolutions particularly complex is that they deal with policy surrounding
peacekeeping operations, sanctions to offending states and even authorization of military
action - this is all within the security council’s purview. So, some do argue that this sets
up a dynamic where the 15 represented countries could unfairly govern. At issue is also that
the Security Council structure itself is inherently biased. It does not treat all 15 member states
equally. Indeed, it divides its membership between permanent and temporary members. China,
The United States, The United Kingdom, Russia, and France have permanent status within the
council, which has been the case since its inception. The other 10 slots are temporary
and membership is given to a country for a period of only two years - though a single
country can receive membership consecutively. But perhaps the most significant difference
between temporary and permanent members, is that any decision made within the council
can be vetoed by just one of the five permanent members. Thus, this veto power has been largely
criticized as undemocratic - unfairly resting too much power in too few hands. And, since
the council’s inception, more than 200 substantive resolutions have been vetoed by permanent
members. As such, this veto power has been placed by critics at the root of inaction...Like
when Russia and China vetoed a resolution to sanction North Korea’s human rights violations,
which included outsourcing their people to work in slave-like conditions. Which, brings
us to perhaps the largest criticism of the Security Council…that, with the countless
ongoing wars and human rights violations, it well, fails at its aims to maintain security
and peace. Nonetheless, what the UN does accomplish should not be dismissed, including the more
than 60 peacekeeping missions impacting millions of lives. But, to learn more about the United
Nation’s effectiveness head on over to our friends at Test Tube News, by clicking here.
Thanks for watching, and be sure to subscribe.
with respect to the structure of the UN Security Council, a group of 15 countries in charge
of identifying threats to peace and determining the appropriate course of action. Recently,
India has brought up concerns that many nations, including themselves and countries within
Africa, are not being fairly represented. So, it got us wondering, how does the UN Security
Council work and why are so many countries upset with the way it’s run? Well, The United
Nations as a whole was established after World War II with 51 founding countries on board
- though today 193 countries participate. Its aim is to maintain peace and security.
It has developed multiple programs and 6 main governing bodies in areas like economics,
human rights, and social policy. But, arguably one of the most contentious parts of the UN
is The UN Security Council. The contention stems largely from the council’s power,
structure, and effectiveness. In terms of power, it is the only body in the UN that
can issue binding resolutions to other states. If the 15 member council passes a substantive
resolution, all 193 member, are obligated to follow through. As you can imagine, member
states at large do not always agree with the council, which has led to some instances of
dissent. What makes these resolutions particularly complex is that they deal with policy surrounding
peacekeeping operations, sanctions to offending states and even authorization of military
action - this is all within the security council’s purview. So, some do argue that this sets
up a dynamic where the 15 represented countries could unfairly govern. At issue is also that
the Security Council structure itself is inherently biased. It does not treat all 15 member states
equally. Indeed, it divides its membership between permanent and temporary members. China,
The United States, The United Kingdom, Russia, and France have permanent status within the
council, which has been the case since its inception. The other 10 slots are temporary
and membership is given to a country for a period of only two years - though a single
country can receive membership consecutively. But perhaps the most significant difference
between temporary and permanent members, is that any decision made within the council
can be vetoed by just one of the five permanent members. Thus, this veto power has been largely
criticized as undemocratic - unfairly resting too much power in too few hands. And, since
the council’s inception, more than 200 substantive resolutions have been vetoed by permanent
members. As such, this veto power has been placed by critics at the root of inaction...Like
when Russia and China vetoed a resolution to sanction North Korea’s human rights violations,
which included outsourcing their people to work in slave-like conditions. Which, brings
us to perhaps the largest criticism of the Security Council…that, with the countless
ongoing wars and human rights violations, it well, fails at its aims to maintain security
and peace. Nonetheless, what the UN does accomplish should not be dismissed, including the more
than 60 peacekeeping missions impacting millions of lives. But, to learn more about the United
Nation’s effectiveness head on over to our friends at Test Tube News, by clicking here.
Thanks for watching, and be sure to subscribe.