YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 37 lines · added Dec 12, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

For nearly 70 years, India and Bangladesh have been facing one of the world’s weirdest
territorial disputes. Essentially Bangladesh and India overlap and weave in and out of
each other’s borders, creating territories within territories within territories - or
enclaves. In fact, there were 162 of these “enclaves.” Which has caused many problems
for residents.. But now a treaty may resolve this decades old issue. So what does this
actually mean for the people that live there? First, how did the borders end up being so
blurred in the first place? Well, no one really knows... There’s the theory that a drunk
mapper spilled ink on a map and the more likely possibility that it was a result of failed
conquest - that in the 1700s the Mughal empire attempted to conquer a huge area but ended
up with parts instead. Up until recently, if you were say, a member of a small enclave,
you’d likely have limited access to hospitals, schools, and the services provided by the
surrounding country’s government. In theory, things as simple as going to the grocery store
would require a visa if the store were outside of boundaries - but the only way to get a
visa might be to travel through the foreign country’s territory to get to your parent
country’s major city. So it caused all sorts of issues with statehood and made people de
facto criminals by necessity… The newly ratified treaty was meant to solve these issues
by having the enclaves be absorbed by their respective surrounding country. As one report
explains, the “lives of more than 50,000 people who resided in these enclaves in Cooch
Behar...Where they had been surrounded by a country they didn't have citizenship in
for decades... will finally gain access to things like schools, electricity and health
care.” The agreement also stipulated that people would be given the option of either
accepting the new country’s citizenship or retain the former…their choice. So one
might think that this would be a happy ending for all. But the thing is…. if residents
chose to retain their former citizenship, they are forced to relocate, which is causing
heartache for families whose members chose different citizenships. On top of this, bureaucratic
inefficiencies meant that some were left off records and have now become stateless. Moreover,
the government’s administrative failures have caused huge problems for those who owned
land, as they may now be in danger of losing it. One can only hope that these logistical
errors will be addressed in a timely fashion and that the government will provide the ex-enclave
residents with what was promised in the India Bangladesh agreement. But, administrative
issues aside... though now clearly delineated on maps, these enclaves are far from being
just Bangladesh and India. The migration of people to and from former enclaves, remind
us that while these boundaries appear linear on maps; Ultimately, it is the people, their
history, and ideas that truly define identity and borders. But for more on the 2,500 mile
long fence that India is building on its border with Bangladesh, which upon completion will
be the longest border fence in the world, check out our other video by clicking now.
Thanks for watching, please subscribe.

Need subtitles from another video?