YouSub
Should Foreigners Be Allowed To Hire Surrogates In India

en English

Should Foreigners Be Allowed To Hire Surrogates In India English subtitles

0 downloads · 40 lines · added Jan 10, 2016

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Often the only viable choice for couples who wish to have their own biological children,
commercial surrogacy is a multi-billion dollar industry. In India alone, it amounts to more
than 2 billion dollars and about 5,000 surrogate children per year. So why is India now considering
a ban on commercial surrogacy services for singles and foreign couples? Well, first we
should discuss why India has become so popular for surrogacy in the first place. Part of
it has to do with the fact that it’s one of the few countries like Russia and Ukraine
that allows commercial surrogacy at all. Most countries have banned it or have no legislation
that addresses it. In some places, like Hong Kong, Canada, and some parts of Australia,
it’s even considered a criminal offense. And the other major reason is cost. While
some parts of the United States allow it for example, it costs upwards of 100,000 dollars,
which can be 2 times more than going with a surrogacy center in India. And for some
Indian women, bearing another couple’s biological child is attractive because it pays relatively
well. For example, a woman who might make $120 a year doing farmwork or domestic housekeeping,
can instead earn thousands dollars once the baby is delivered. While the exact figure
is disputed, some of these surrogate mothers report that without this income, they would
have never been able to build a house, start a business, or provide an education for their
children… Which is also where the problem comes in for some critics who argue that these
women are mostly poor illiterate women who are being exploited, this is partly why a
ban is being considered in India. The underlying assumption here is that informed consent is
not a possibility when wealth disparity is so great. Still, others argue that, until
they have another viable choice, this is a life-changing opportunity that makes the most
economic sense for them. But economics aside, some believe it is immoral to bear another’s
child. The issue here is that it is selfish to expend resources in artificially bringing
in another child into the world when resources are scarce and there are already so many children
who are in need of adoption. This however, dismisses that in some cases, it is much more
difficult or costly to adopt a child than to have one through surrogacy. For homosexual
couples, adoption is often prohibited, so surrogacy is their only choice… for these
couples, India was often the only real possibility. As it became more popular with these couples,
awareness and fear among those who believe homosexuals should not bear children also
rose…a huge reason why India is now effectively banning surrogacy to homosexuals - only allowing
surrogacy for married heterosexual couples in India or of Indian descent. Ethics aside,
some believe the answer lies not in banning commercial surrogacy for foreigners, but in
better regulation; because if banned, commercial surrogacy would simply go underground where
surrogate mothers, babies and intended parents alike, would be at greater risk. Should India
manage to pass the bill banning surrogacy for singles, homosexuals, and foreigners,
it may cease to be the surrogacy hub that it is today, but what the international response
will entail remains unclear. Another form of international tourism that is mediated
by inexpensive price points is cosmetic surgery in South Korea. Many westerners are booking
tickets to get their cosmetic surgery done for cheap. For more on that, click here now.
Thanks for watching, and please subscribe.

Need subtitles from another video?