Advertisement
English transcript
As more mass shootings grow into a daily occurrence in the US, it seems we can’t turn to lawmakers
for solutions, but can we turn to science?
Science can tell us a lot. About the world around us, the universe beyond, even what’s
going on in the cells in our finger tips. But it can’t tell us a whole lot about gun
violence. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the National Institute
of Health (NIH) have been banned from getting any kind of federal funding for firearm related
studies for the last 20 years.
In 1996, Former Republican Congressman Jay Dickey of Arkansas pushed for an amendment
on a funding bill that forbid the use of federal funds on studies that “promote gun control.
A move he’s come to later regret, he even told NPR that he wants “science and science
investigation and examination to take the place of politics”. He originally meant
for the bill to stop “the collection of data to go to gun control advocacy” But
the vague language put the brakes on any further research. Scientists just became too scared
that they would lose their funding if they studied gun violence, and rightfully so.
Congress retroactively punished the CDC for carrying out gun research the previous year.
In 1995, the CDC spent 2.6 million dollars on gun violence research. At first some members
of congress wanted to strip all the funding for the entire CDC’s injury control center,
a total of over 40 million dollars. But they compromised for taking just the same amount
that had been spent on gun violence the previous year, 2.6 million. With such large sums at
risk, scientists were scared to study it and “Sponsors were spooked to fund stuff that
had to do with guns” according to one researcher from Duke University.
So it’s no wonder we know so little. I mean over the past four decades, NIH has funded
just three studies on gun violence. Check out a comparison of NIH studies. They have
studied disease like rabies, cholera, and polio. Take rabies for example. It killed
just 63 people globally from the years 1973 to 2012. The NIH completed 89 studies on it.
In comparison, over the same time period gun violence killed over 4 million people, yet
the NIH completed just 3 studies on the subject.
You might be saying, "But guns aren’t diseases!" But the fact is, research organizations like
the CDC and the NIH study other things potentially harmful to human health besides diseases,
like deaths by drowning or car accidents. And even if they study these things, they
aren’t suggesting we ban pools or cars, they are just interested in making them SAFER.
And in 2013, President Obama agreed. After the wake of the horrific Newtown Elementary
School Shooting, he gave an executive order that the CDC and the NIH return to researching
gun violence. But unfortunately, not much has changed. Congress still blocks funding
on firearms when they can and researchers are still left quaking in their sensible shoes.
CDC spokeswoman Courtney Lenard told the Washington Post that “It is possible for us to conduct
firearm-related research...but our resources are very limited.”
So what do researchers know about gun violence? Well according to the CDC we know that around
33,600 people die every year from firearms across all categories. That’s about the
same number as those who die from car accidents. And from the few studies available, like one
published in the New England Journal of Medicine, found that having a gun in the home is linked
with an increase in the risk of homicide in the home. Other risk factors include substance
abuse and a history of violence. And another study from the Journal of Epidemiology found
that having a gun in the home increases the risk of suicide for adult men.
But there are so many basic questions we have yet to answer. For starters, no one knows
how many guns are out there in the US. There’s no national registry. We don’t know why
people want to own a gun or even what percentage of gun owners go on to commit a crime with
their firearm. Basic things that science needs to answer. Like Richard Berk, a criminology
professor at the University of Pennsylvania said in a letter to Joe Biden, “I see no
upside to ignorance”. So I guess more research is needed.
I know I know, you’re probably sick of hearing about gun violence and mass shootings. But
these events are just as horrific even the 300th time around. So why have we stopped
caring about mass shootings? Have we become desensitized? Trace has the answer in this
video, right here.
for solutions, but can we turn to science?
Science can tell us a lot. About the world around us, the universe beyond, even what’s
going on in the cells in our finger tips. But it can’t tell us a whole lot about gun
violence. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the National Institute
of Health (NIH) have been banned from getting any kind of federal funding for firearm related
studies for the last 20 years.
In 1996, Former Republican Congressman Jay Dickey of Arkansas pushed for an amendment
on a funding bill that forbid the use of federal funds on studies that “promote gun control.
A move he’s come to later regret, he even told NPR that he wants “science and science
investigation and examination to take the place of politics”. He originally meant
for the bill to stop “the collection of data to go to gun control advocacy” But
the vague language put the brakes on any further research. Scientists just became too scared
that they would lose their funding if they studied gun violence, and rightfully so.
Congress retroactively punished the CDC for carrying out gun research the previous year.
In 1995, the CDC spent 2.6 million dollars on gun violence research. At first some members
of congress wanted to strip all the funding for the entire CDC’s injury control center,
a total of over 40 million dollars. But they compromised for taking just the same amount
that had been spent on gun violence the previous year, 2.6 million. With such large sums at
risk, scientists were scared to study it and “Sponsors were spooked to fund stuff that
had to do with guns” according to one researcher from Duke University.
So it’s no wonder we know so little. I mean over the past four decades, NIH has funded
just three studies on gun violence. Check out a comparison of NIH studies. They have
studied disease like rabies, cholera, and polio. Take rabies for example. It killed
just 63 people globally from the years 1973 to 2012. The NIH completed 89 studies on it.
In comparison, over the same time period gun violence killed over 4 million people, yet
the NIH completed just 3 studies on the subject.
You might be saying, "But guns aren’t diseases!" But the fact is, research organizations like
the CDC and the NIH study other things potentially harmful to human health besides diseases,
like deaths by drowning or car accidents. And even if they study these things, they
aren’t suggesting we ban pools or cars, they are just interested in making them SAFER.
And in 2013, President Obama agreed. After the wake of the horrific Newtown Elementary
School Shooting, he gave an executive order that the CDC and the NIH return to researching
gun violence. But unfortunately, not much has changed. Congress still blocks funding
on firearms when they can and researchers are still left quaking in their sensible shoes.
CDC spokeswoman Courtney Lenard told the Washington Post that “It is possible for us to conduct
firearm-related research...but our resources are very limited.”
So what do researchers know about gun violence? Well according to the CDC we know that around
33,600 people die every year from firearms across all categories. That’s about the
same number as those who die from car accidents. And from the few studies available, like one
published in the New England Journal of Medicine, found that having a gun in the home is linked
with an increase in the risk of homicide in the home. Other risk factors include substance
abuse and a history of violence. And another study from the Journal of Epidemiology found
that having a gun in the home increases the risk of suicide for adult men.
But there are so many basic questions we have yet to answer. For starters, no one knows
how many guns are out there in the US. There’s no national registry. We don’t know why
people want to own a gun or even what percentage of gun owners go on to commit a crime with
their firearm. Basic things that science needs to answer. Like Richard Berk, a criminology
professor at the University of Pennsylvania said in a letter to Joe Biden, “I see no
upside to ignorance”. So I guess more research is needed.
I know I know, you’re probably sick of hearing about gun violence and mass shootings. But
these events are just as horrific even the 300th time around. So why have we stopped
caring about mass shootings? Have we become desensitized? Trace has the answer in this
video, right here.