Advertisement
English transcript
The debate over gun control has deep roots
in the United States.
And the fatal shooting in Washington DC
will most likely heat that up again.
Thanks for tuning in to D News everyone.
I'm Trace.
Police in Washington DC are still gathering all the facts
as they investigate the shooting at the US Navy Yard
earlier today.
At the time of this recording, CNN
has reported that at least 12 people died,
including one of the suspected gunman.
During times of gun violence, debates inevitably
rise about how guns fit into our society.
A new study published in the American Journal
of Public Health is making a bold claim.
It says, states where gun ownership is higher experience
a higher number of firearm related homicides.
This flies directly in the face of some gun advocates who
cite the 1998 book, More Guns Less Crime
by John Lott Jr. Where gun controls effect on crime
is thrown up against a lot of data.
This book and others like it contain data
from various sources compiled in such a way as
to push gun ownership as a more sensible solution
to deter crime.
This new three decade data heavy study however,
indicates a contradictory finding.
The Boston University School of Public Health
looked at CDC records from 1981 to 2010,
and found as the number of guns in the state increased by 1%,
the number of homicides with guns increased 0.9%.
The researchers pointed out that they're not
saying that more guns causes more killings in these places,
but that over three decades the number of killings
and the number of guns were tied into this is very similar pace.
The assertion isn't particularly new.
The Harvard injury control research center
found the same thing in 2012.
And their data showed even when controlling
for every other variable, more guns correlate to increased
homicides.
Even if you take the whole United States out
of the reckoning and only look at other countries,
they found that since 1990 across 26
developed countries where more guns were available
there were more homicides.
Other studies in the last 10 years
have found similar results.
Regardless of how you come down on the great gun debate,
these studies are compelling, though not causal.
Not one of these studies does claim or even can claim,
more guns means more homicide.
But guns and crime seem to increase and decrease together
across race, gender, age, type of crime, urbanization, alcohol
consumption, employment, and income level in all counties,
cities, regions, states, and countries studied.
Data like this tends to put people
on both sides of the gun debate on their warpaths.
Gun advocates claim since the 1990s gun ownership has
increased and thus crime has dropped.
And though that it's true crime has dropped,
there is no way to prove causality they're either.
A number of gun homicides have dropped overall.
But so has all crime in the United States.
And this Boston University studied still applies.
So though crime is down overall and gun homicide
is down overall, the greatest number of gun homicides
are found where there are a lot of guns around.
For some reason, we're not sure.
Researchers are working on the answers
as to why right as we speak.
Check out the Pew Research Center
social and demographic study for some really interesting reasons
on why crime may be dropping.
So what do you think of this study?
Share your thoughts with us in the comments.
And hey, this is science.
So let's try to point to actual signs here too guys.
And not just anecdotes or personal experiences.
Let's have a discussion.
Thanks for watching D News today.
Click Subscribe so you can get more
D News every day of the week.
in the United States.
And the fatal shooting in Washington DC
will most likely heat that up again.
Thanks for tuning in to D News everyone.
I'm Trace.
Police in Washington DC are still gathering all the facts
as they investigate the shooting at the US Navy Yard
earlier today.
At the time of this recording, CNN
has reported that at least 12 people died,
including one of the suspected gunman.
During times of gun violence, debates inevitably
rise about how guns fit into our society.
A new study published in the American Journal
of Public Health is making a bold claim.
It says, states where gun ownership is higher experience
a higher number of firearm related homicides.
This flies directly in the face of some gun advocates who
cite the 1998 book, More Guns Less Crime
by John Lott Jr. Where gun controls effect on crime
is thrown up against a lot of data.
This book and others like it contain data
from various sources compiled in such a way as
to push gun ownership as a more sensible solution
to deter crime.
This new three decade data heavy study however,
indicates a contradictory finding.
The Boston University School of Public Health
looked at CDC records from 1981 to 2010,
and found as the number of guns in the state increased by 1%,
the number of homicides with guns increased 0.9%.
The researchers pointed out that they're not
saying that more guns causes more killings in these places,
but that over three decades the number of killings
and the number of guns were tied into this is very similar pace.
The assertion isn't particularly new.
The Harvard injury control research center
found the same thing in 2012.
And their data showed even when controlling
for every other variable, more guns correlate to increased
homicides.
Even if you take the whole United States out
of the reckoning and only look at other countries,
they found that since 1990 across 26
developed countries where more guns were available
there were more homicides.
Other studies in the last 10 years
have found similar results.
Regardless of how you come down on the great gun debate,
these studies are compelling, though not causal.
Not one of these studies does claim or even can claim,
more guns means more homicide.
But guns and crime seem to increase and decrease together
across race, gender, age, type of crime, urbanization, alcohol
consumption, employment, and income level in all counties,
cities, regions, states, and countries studied.
Data like this tends to put people
on both sides of the gun debate on their warpaths.
Gun advocates claim since the 1990s gun ownership has
increased and thus crime has dropped.
And though that it's true crime has dropped,
there is no way to prove causality they're either.
A number of gun homicides have dropped overall.
But so has all crime in the United States.
And this Boston University studied still applies.
So though crime is down overall and gun homicide
is down overall, the greatest number of gun homicides
are found where there are a lot of guns around.
For some reason, we're not sure.
Researchers are working on the answers
as to why right as we speak.
Check out the Pew Research Center
social and demographic study for some really interesting reasons
on why crime may be dropping.
So what do you think of this study?
Share your thoughts with us in the comments.
And hey, this is science.
So let's try to point to actual signs here too guys.
And not just anecdotes or personal experiences.
Let's have a discussion.
Thanks for watching D News today.
Click Subscribe so you can get more
D News every day of the week.