Advertisement
English transcript
That product looks organic.
Should I buy it?
Here, here, let me hold it.
Whoa, I'm getting it.
[MUSIC PLAYING]
Hey, shoppers, this is D News, and I'm Trace.
When you're at the store how do you feel about labels like
"cage-free," "organic," "not tested on animals,"
"phosphate-free."
Are these claims more likely to make you buy an item?
And new study in the Journal of Business Ethics says you will,
especially if it goes in or on your body.
Researchers from the Concordia University School of Business
determined when we touch products
with labels like "organic," we receive
what's called a positive contagion effect.
When we come in contact with or eat something
that has an ethical feel to it, we
believe those ethical benefits are transferred into us-- which
I have to say is kind of weird, but totally true.
They did the research to find other products that
could be labeled with ethical branding.
Printer ink, for example, we don't touch,
so saying biodegradable won't help its sales.
But moisturizer or paper towel, we touch a lot,
and every positive touch reinforces our feelings
of ethical awesomeness.
We explained on D News a few months back--
organic foods are not more nutritious than other foods,
though this positive contagion effect does make us feel better
about eating them.
And "organic" doesn't really mean what we think it means.
In this country, the US Department of Agriculture
took over the term "organic" in 2002.
It is defined as having been produced using methods which,
quote, "integrate cultural, biological,
and mechanical practices that foster cycling of resources,
promote ecological balance, and conserve biodiversity."
Additionally, things like synthetic fertilizers, sewage,
or genetic engineering can't be used.
However, chickens in a cage-- still organic.
As are cows packed into a barn eating
genetically modified grain.
The grain isn't organic, but the cow still is.
Some farmers and activists don't agree with this definition,
so they've created other terms, like "pastured," meaning
an animal was literally raised in a pasture.
The Northeast Organic Farming Association
created its own "Certified Naturally Grown" label,
which has similar requirements to USDA but without control
of the USDA.
Labeling is getting crazy.
As of now, only a small fraction of the 2.2 million farms
in the United States have been labeled USDA-certified organic.
The rest can't use the word "organic"
without paying fees and navigating
through federal requirements, lest they
be slapped with a $20,000 fine.
And "organic" isn't the only label you commonly see
nowadays. "Cage-free" just means no cages.
That's all it means.
"Free range" means they're provided an area
to go outside, though that area can be fenced and covered
and at the far end of a barn.
"Grass-fed" means the animals are fed mainly grass,
but they can still use pesticides, hormones,
and antibiotics, and feed them grain as long as, again,
it's mostly grass.
So knowing all of this, do you still
feel that positive contagion effect with organic products?
Are they still ethical?
We'd like to believe so, but without further research,
we can't really be sure.
What do you think of all this labeling business?
Do you even care?
Tell us so we know if we should explore
this more in the comments below, and subscribe for more D News.
Thanks for watching, everybody.
Should I buy it?
Here, here, let me hold it.
Whoa, I'm getting it.
[MUSIC PLAYING]
Hey, shoppers, this is D News, and I'm Trace.
When you're at the store how do you feel about labels like
"cage-free," "organic," "not tested on animals,"
"phosphate-free."
Are these claims more likely to make you buy an item?
And new study in the Journal of Business Ethics says you will,
especially if it goes in or on your body.
Researchers from the Concordia University School of Business
determined when we touch products
with labels like "organic," we receive
what's called a positive contagion effect.
When we come in contact with or eat something
that has an ethical feel to it, we
believe those ethical benefits are transferred into us-- which
I have to say is kind of weird, but totally true.
They did the research to find other products that
could be labeled with ethical branding.
Printer ink, for example, we don't touch,
so saying biodegradable won't help its sales.
But moisturizer or paper towel, we touch a lot,
and every positive touch reinforces our feelings
of ethical awesomeness.
We explained on D News a few months back--
organic foods are not more nutritious than other foods,
though this positive contagion effect does make us feel better
about eating them.
And "organic" doesn't really mean what we think it means.
In this country, the US Department of Agriculture
took over the term "organic" in 2002.
It is defined as having been produced using methods which,
quote, "integrate cultural, biological,
and mechanical practices that foster cycling of resources,
promote ecological balance, and conserve biodiversity."
Additionally, things like synthetic fertilizers, sewage,
or genetic engineering can't be used.
However, chickens in a cage-- still organic.
As are cows packed into a barn eating
genetically modified grain.
The grain isn't organic, but the cow still is.
Some farmers and activists don't agree with this definition,
so they've created other terms, like "pastured," meaning
an animal was literally raised in a pasture.
The Northeast Organic Farming Association
created its own "Certified Naturally Grown" label,
which has similar requirements to USDA but without control
of the USDA.
Labeling is getting crazy.
As of now, only a small fraction of the 2.2 million farms
in the United States have been labeled USDA-certified organic.
The rest can't use the word "organic"
without paying fees and navigating
through federal requirements, lest they
be slapped with a $20,000 fine.
And "organic" isn't the only label you commonly see
nowadays. "Cage-free" just means no cages.
That's all it means.
"Free range" means they're provided an area
to go outside, though that area can be fenced and covered
and at the far end of a barn.
"Grass-fed" means the animals are fed mainly grass,
but they can still use pesticides, hormones,
and antibiotics, and feed them grain as long as, again,
it's mostly grass.
So knowing all of this, do you still
feel that positive contagion effect with organic products?
Are they still ethical?
We'd like to believe so, but without further research,
we can't really be sure.
What do you think of all this labeling business?
Do you even care?
Tell us so we know if we should explore
this more in the comments below, and subscribe for more D News.
Thanks for watching, everybody.