YouSub
Does The Placebo Effect Work On You

en English

Does The Placebo Effect Work On You English subtitles

0 downloads · 46 lines · added Feb 7, 2016

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

The placebo effect is so weird. How does the power of placebo work? Is it all in your head?
Well new research suggests it might all be in your genes.
Hey guys! Julia here for DNews
The placebo effect fascinates me. How can a sugar pill heal someone just with the power
of belief? This effect is probably the basis for a lot of ancient medicine. Where spells,
powders, and rituals ruled the day. A lot of pomp and circumstance would certainly convince
most people of the power of the medicine.
But it’s not just in the past. Even today, most doctors admit to prescribing a placebo…
i mean, antibiotics for a cold!? REALLY!? but doctors aren’t dumb, they are just trying
to make you feel better. Maybe just going to the doctor, being in a doctor’s office,
the whole shebang can make you feel better, just like a healing ritual would have done
thousands of years ago. Even if it’s just all in your head.
But in some cases even knowing it’s a placebo doesn’t change the outcome. One study published
in PLOS One found that even if researchers say “this is a sugar pill” and write placebo
on the bottle, the patients reported improvement in their symptoms! So it really does seem
like the doctor-patient relationship has a lot to do with it.
But while placebos might seem like a magical cure, not everyone is susceptible to the effect.
In a review published in the journal Trends in Molecular Medicine, researchers from Beth
Israel Deaconess Medical Center and from Brigham and Women's Hospital introduce the idea of
a placebome. Or the idea that your genes affect whether or not the placebo effect will work
on you. This could explain decades of strange results with placebos.
Not everyone responds to them. Most research suggests that placebos improve health in both
subjective and objective measures in 30-40% of people. While that’s still not most people,
that’s a pretty large percentage.
One of the first studies to suggest a genetic link, was published in 2008, in the journal
Neuroscience. The study found that placebos, in this case a sugar pill, worked in treating
anxiety in 40% of the trial participants who got it. The researchers found those who took
the sugar pill had decreased activity in the amygdala, suggesting that the placebo worked
through the same mechanisms as the active drug in the trial.
The study also analyzed genes that regulate serotonin in the brain. The researchers found
that only people with certain alleles or types of genes had that regulation of activity in
the amygdala.
In another study in 2012, one of the researchers from Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center
found a specific gene which acts on dopamine in the brain. She found that people with a
different version of the gene responded differently to placebos.
Maybe because people with the different gene have different levels of dopamine available
in the prefrontal cortex. Dopamine has been implicated in the “confirmation bias”
feeling. So maybe people with this gene expect the drug to work, so they look for confirmation
of this expectation. So even if they are getting a sugar pill, the soothing words of the doctor
confirms their expectation that the drug will work.
It’ll certainly be an interesting area of research to keep an eye on. And it raises
a lot of issues like, it suggests that placebos run through the same neurotransmitters as
drug responses. Which could have a huge impact on the way we research drugs. Do placebos
and drugs interact? Should drug trials always include a “no-treatment” group?
So what do you think? If placebos work, are they really that bad? Sound off in the comments
below.

Need subtitles from another video?