Advertisement
English transcript
It's in our schools, it's in our homes, it's at our coffee shops, and it's on our minds
constantly. Homework. And it's DEADLY. Just kidding, it's fine, but is there such a thing
as too much?
Homework is something we've all been assigned; even Harry Potter had tons of homework! But,
sadly, for us science muggles, Hermione won't be able help us out; which is actually better,
it turns out. In the early 1900s, homework was part and parcel to creating a "disciplined
mind," then in the 1940s, it was seen as superfluous, until the 1950s when the Soviets kicked off
the Space Race with the launch of Sputnik. As homework's relevance ebbs and flows, new
research from the American Psychological Association has planted a flag right in the middle -- finding
the benefits of homework are real, unless it's over-assigned.
Surveying and studying 77-hundred students, the APA determined students spent between
one and two hours on homework for all their subjects. If the teacher assigned a moderate
amount of homework systematically, with strategy, the students did better on assessments in
math and science. They also did better if they did the work on their own, so BACK OFF
HER-MI-OH-NINNY. Researchers looking at the number of minutes spent related to gains made
in scholastic abilities found anything over 70 minutes per day wasn't efficient. "HOW
is more important than HOW MUCH," they said.
The strategy of homework, it turns out, can be much more difficult than it sounds. Homework
in Elementary school has no evidence of any benefit,, whereas junior high and high school
do see increasing gains, but even then they've found autonomy in learning is better; when
parents get too involved the student suffers. It's not just the students and parents, though,
a 2012 study of 18,000 10th-grade students found (quote) "homework should be purposeful,
and that purpose must be understood by both the teachers and the students… more is not
better." I loved school, but I wasn't the best student when it came to homework; I didn't
always understand WHY I we were doing it, it just seemed like busywork -- which these
researchers say is part of the problem.
On top of that, everyone learns differently. Standardized tests and letter grades aren't
the best for everyone, true. And for people with ADHD, like me, it can be very difficult
to sit for hours at a time. Research shows studying also benefits from changing locations,
and trying out different strategies for different topics. Even sleep can help us learn!
Psychological Science in the Public Interest ranked 10 different forms and tactics for
learning. The best were practice testing, and distributed practice. Distributed practice
involves revisiting topics 10-20 percent of the time you want to recall it. Want to remember
something for a week? Study the topic once every 12-24 hours apart. Practice tests involve
testing your OWN knowledge. Sure you can have a pre-created test, but a better way is to
make your own practice questions while studying, and come back to them days later. Flashcards
are an example of practice testing. The worst ways to recall long-term critical thinking
information? Summarization, highlighting, mnemonics, re-reading and imagery for text
learning.
These aren't hard and fast rules of course -- Each has a benefit for a different TYPE
of learning. Our brains are made of meat, remember, we're better at remembering some
things than others because of our evolution. We needed to learn game paths, safe havens,
or which bush had the best berries. Simply assigning reams of rote memorization or repetitive
problem solving isn't going to work for every one of those brains. Experiences, or revisiting
topics days or even a week later can help recall. Homework is an important part of an
overall learning strategy; just like knowing yourself, and how you learn.
How do YOU learn? Have you thought about it?
constantly. Homework. And it's DEADLY. Just kidding, it's fine, but is there such a thing
as too much?
Homework is something we've all been assigned; even Harry Potter had tons of homework! But,
sadly, for us science muggles, Hermione won't be able help us out; which is actually better,
it turns out. In the early 1900s, homework was part and parcel to creating a "disciplined
mind," then in the 1940s, it was seen as superfluous, until the 1950s when the Soviets kicked off
the Space Race with the launch of Sputnik. As homework's relevance ebbs and flows, new
research from the American Psychological Association has planted a flag right in the middle -- finding
the benefits of homework are real, unless it's over-assigned.
Surveying and studying 77-hundred students, the APA determined students spent between
one and two hours on homework for all their subjects. If the teacher assigned a moderate
amount of homework systematically, with strategy, the students did better on assessments in
math and science. They also did better if they did the work on their own, so BACK OFF
HER-MI-OH-NINNY. Researchers looking at the number of minutes spent related to gains made
in scholastic abilities found anything over 70 minutes per day wasn't efficient. "HOW
is more important than HOW MUCH," they said.
The strategy of homework, it turns out, can be much more difficult than it sounds. Homework
in Elementary school has no evidence of any benefit,, whereas junior high and high school
do see increasing gains, but even then they've found autonomy in learning is better; when
parents get too involved the student suffers. It's not just the students and parents, though,
a 2012 study of 18,000 10th-grade students found (quote) "homework should be purposeful,
and that purpose must be understood by both the teachers and the students… more is not
better." I loved school, but I wasn't the best student when it came to homework; I didn't
always understand WHY I we were doing it, it just seemed like busywork -- which these
researchers say is part of the problem.
On top of that, everyone learns differently. Standardized tests and letter grades aren't
the best for everyone, true. And for people with ADHD, like me, it can be very difficult
to sit for hours at a time. Research shows studying also benefits from changing locations,
and trying out different strategies for different topics. Even sleep can help us learn!
Psychological Science in the Public Interest ranked 10 different forms and tactics for
learning. The best were practice testing, and distributed practice. Distributed practice
involves revisiting topics 10-20 percent of the time you want to recall it. Want to remember
something for a week? Study the topic once every 12-24 hours apart. Practice tests involve
testing your OWN knowledge. Sure you can have a pre-created test, but a better way is to
make your own practice questions while studying, and come back to them days later. Flashcards
are an example of practice testing. The worst ways to recall long-term critical thinking
information? Summarization, highlighting, mnemonics, re-reading and imagery for text
learning.
These aren't hard and fast rules of course -- Each has a benefit for a different TYPE
of learning. Our brains are made of meat, remember, we're better at remembering some
things than others because of our evolution. We needed to learn game paths, safe havens,
or which bush had the best berries. Simply assigning reams of rote memorization or repetitive
problem solving isn't going to work for every one of those brains. Experiences, or revisiting
topics days or even a week later can help recall. Homework is an important part of an
overall learning strategy; just like knowing yourself, and how you learn.
How do YOU learn? Have you thought about it?