Advertisement
English transcript
Out of fake gods and bad gods and demi-gods and would-be gods. Out of the whole pantheon,
which god makes societies better?
Hey guys, Julia here for DNews
Recently the idea that belief in one “big god” lead to the rise of complex societies
held sway in research circles. But that’s being challenged by new research published
in the journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B.[1]
So this is a story of different types of religion, there’s more monotheistic religions with
a “Moralizing High God” or one supreme being that hands out morality and punishment,
and religions that have “Broad Supernatural Punishment”, which can be loosely polytheistic,
meaning many gods and includes things like ancestral spirits and concepts like karma.
Previous research showed that belief in a “Moralizing High God (MHG)” allowed societies
to become more politically sophisticated.
This research seems to refute that. It showed that religions with multiple deities or spirits
or karma type punishments lead to more complex societies, but religions with one “head
honcho” did not.
But how does a belief in any kind of religion build complex societies? Well thinking you’re
gonna be punished if you do something wrong, even if no one is looking, is a pretty good
deterrent or it might make us more likely to cooperate. One study published in the Journal
of Personality and Social Psychology showed that people become less hostile in a threatening
situation when they’re reminded of their religious beliefs. This is especially important
when life gets tough. [2]
Another study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences found
that those who live in harsh environments tend to believe in “big Gods”. They think
these beliefs drive people to be more pro-social when conditions make it hard to survive. Cooperation,
even if it’s costly to the individual, could enable a group to thrive in times of stress.[3]
But it seemed like an age old tale of correlation not causation. Some studies show it’s the
other way around, as societies get more complex they're more likely to have one central guy
in the sky. One study published in the journal Current Biology found that as a society became
more affluent, it triggered more moralizing types of religions. [4]
Which gets us back to the most recent research. So, the team of researchers of various Australian
institutions looked at 96 Asian Pacific cultures, because these Austronesian cultures are well
documented and less influenced by main single deity religions like Christianity and Islam.
They found that belief in a head honcho deity did not drive or sustain the evolution of
political complexity, but rather it tends to come along for the ride. The research also
suggests that it’s belief in broad supernatural entities like ancestral spirits or karma actually
smoothed the way for cultures to become complex. And that makes sense, just look at history,
there’s plenty of examples of cultures without High Moralizing Gods, like the Greeks and
Romans and Mayans, who built incredibly sophisticated societies.
Maybe because of the cooperative motives I mentioned earlier or maybe not so nobly, the
supernatural gives more weight to your claim to authority and power. If you say you’re
in contact with these gods, or that these gods are your ancestors, people are gonna
believe you and maybe follow you.
So this research is still in it’s early stage and clearly needs more study. And it’s
not like you have to be religious to have a complex cooperative society anyway. Other
studies show that "Some of the most cooperative modern societies are also the most secular".[5]
But how does this new research make you feel about the role of religion in society? Let
us know in the comments below. And don’t forget to hit those like and subscribe buttons
and keep coming back for new episodes every day of the week.
which god makes societies better?
Hey guys, Julia here for DNews
Recently the idea that belief in one “big god” lead to the rise of complex societies
held sway in research circles. But that’s being challenged by new research published
in the journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B.[1]
So this is a story of different types of religion, there’s more monotheistic religions with
a “Moralizing High God” or one supreme being that hands out morality and punishment,
and religions that have “Broad Supernatural Punishment”, which can be loosely polytheistic,
meaning many gods and includes things like ancestral spirits and concepts like karma.
Previous research showed that belief in a “Moralizing High God (MHG)” allowed societies
to become more politically sophisticated.
This research seems to refute that. It showed that religions with multiple deities or spirits
or karma type punishments lead to more complex societies, but religions with one “head
honcho” did not.
But how does a belief in any kind of religion build complex societies? Well thinking you’re
gonna be punished if you do something wrong, even if no one is looking, is a pretty good
deterrent or it might make us more likely to cooperate. One study published in the Journal
of Personality and Social Psychology showed that people become less hostile in a threatening
situation when they’re reminded of their religious beliefs. This is especially important
when life gets tough. [2]
Another study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences found
that those who live in harsh environments tend to believe in “big Gods”. They think
these beliefs drive people to be more pro-social when conditions make it hard to survive. Cooperation,
even if it’s costly to the individual, could enable a group to thrive in times of stress.[3]
But it seemed like an age old tale of correlation not causation. Some studies show it’s the
other way around, as societies get more complex they're more likely to have one central guy
in the sky. One study published in the journal Current Biology found that as a society became
more affluent, it triggered more moralizing types of religions. [4]
Which gets us back to the most recent research. So, the team of researchers of various Australian
institutions looked at 96 Asian Pacific cultures, because these Austronesian cultures are well
documented and less influenced by main single deity religions like Christianity and Islam.
They found that belief in a head honcho deity did not drive or sustain the evolution of
political complexity, but rather it tends to come along for the ride. The research also
suggests that it’s belief in broad supernatural entities like ancestral spirits or karma actually
smoothed the way for cultures to become complex. And that makes sense, just look at history,
there’s plenty of examples of cultures without High Moralizing Gods, like the Greeks and
Romans and Mayans, who built incredibly sophisticated societies.
Maybe because of the cooperative motives I mentioned earlier or maybe not so nobly, the
supernatural gives more weight to your claim to authority and power. If you say you’re
in contact with these gods, or that these gods are your ancestors, people are gonna
believe you and maybe follow you.
So this research is still in it’s early stage and clearly needs more study. And it’s
not like you have to be religious to have a complex cooperative society anyway. Other
studies show that "Some of the most cooperative modern societies are also the most secular".[5]
But how does this new research make you feel about the role of religion in society? Let
us know in the comments below. And don’t forget to hit those like and subscribe buttons
and keep coming back for new episodes every day of the week.