Advertisement
English transcript
Eggs were unhealthy and then healthy. Alcohol is healthy but also dangerous! Butter was
bad, now it's GREAT! WHAT THE HELL SCIENCE!!
Guys, science isn't perfect. It's not! I'm not. We're not. And sometimes it's really
confusing. Some studies show fat is good for you, and more studies show fat is bad you.
Last week, the British Medical Journal released a study claiming the effects of alcohol were
vastly overstated; and that globally, more than three million deaths are attributed to
alcohol consumption. Yet, in the same damn week, Oregon State University says drinking
wine could help you burn fat!!! WHAT THE HELL.
Okay, science isn't law, we in science accept more than one idea at the same time, and we
question constantly. That's hard to do! It's called cognitive dissonance, or the idea that
two opposed ideas can both be held and understood in the same head and. IT'S HARD. There's a
reason we end a lot of our stories with the words, "More research is needed," because
a single study is almost NEVER enough to ascertain actual science. What the media covers on the
other hand… that is completely different.
One notable example of this is butter and cholesterol. As a kid, I remember being taught
that cholesterol is bad. It's all bad. In the 60s, the American Heart Association warned
cholesterol could be bad for the heart. Then, a 1977 study by the Senate Select Committee
on Nutrition and Human Needs resulted in the creation of the "Dietary Goals for the United
States," and cholesterol was branded as a baddie. From there, the government, various
associations, and media spread the word: cholesterol was bad, vitamins were good!
The fourth estate loves sensation and conflict, so people started to avoid butter, eggs, steaks,
bacon and other foods high in cholesterol. The thing is, the science wasn't settled,
it was just popular There's more nuance to this story, and the scientific community protested
the decision. The American Egg Board made a campaign so people would keep eating eggs,
and over the next 50 years, the science slowly pushed people back from the edge.
Researchers told people again and again over the years that fat doesn't cause health problems
on its own. High Density Lipoproteins were discovered in the late 1920s, and Low Density
Lipoproteins in the late 70s, but cholesterol itself is created in your liver and helps
cells form protective membranes. PLUS, it's a building block for vitamin D!
As dietary science progressed, it's been shown that a low-carbohydrate diet is better than
a low-fat diet, but the public's mindset had been set. Nevermind that an epidemic of heart
disease which, in part, prompted this scramble for answers, was hitting the country, or that
the lead researcher only studied populations in the U.S., Japan, and Europe who were selected
because they would confirm the results the researcher wanted.
The thing is, if you lived through this period, you'd assume science kept flip-flopping! But
that's not the case, instead, the peer-reviewed science was consistent and the media and public
were simply sending mixed messages to each other. Now, new science has finally resulted
in the cholesterol guidelines being removed from the 2015 government guidelines. It took
a while, because science takes a while! Longitudinal nutrition studies can take decades to complete,
and have to be giant populations who are heavily scrutinized! This is opposed to cross-sectional
studies, which are a snapshot of a sample, still helpful, but very different. It takes
time to do good science, but we gotta do it.
With this in mind, I would like to say, we at DNews report what is happening in science
as best as we can, but let's be honest, we might make a video next year which says the
exact opposite thing of a video this year! Hopefully, we spot that and point out the
change, because science isn't set, more research is always needed.
bad, now it's GREAT! WHAT THE HELL SCIENCE!!
Guys, science isn't perfect. It's not! I'm not. We're not. And sometimes it's really
confusing. Some studies show fat is good for you, and more studies show fat is bad you.
Last week, the British Medical Journal released a study claiming the effects of alcohol were
vastly overstated; and that globally, more than three million deaths are attributed to
alcohol consumption. Yet, in the same damn week, Oregon State University says drinking
wine could help you burn fat!!! WHAT THE HELL.
Okay, science isn't law, we in science accept more than one idea at the same time, and we
question constantly. That's hard to do! It's called cognitive dissonance, or the idea that
two opposed ideas can both be held and understood in the same head and. IT'S HARD. There's a
reason we end a lot of our stories with the words, "More research is needed," because
a single study is almost NEVER enough to ascertain actual science. What the media covers on the
other hand… that is completely different.
One notable example of this is butter and cholesterol. As a kid, I remember being taught
that cholesterol is bad. It's all bad. In the 60s, the American Heart Association warned
cholesterol could be bad for the heart. Then, a 1977 study by the Senate Select Committee
on Nutrition and Human Needs resulted in the creation of the "Dietary Goals for the United
States," and cholesterol was branded as a baddie. From there, the government, various
associations, and media spread the word: cholesterol was bad, vitamins were good!
The fourth estate loves sensation and conflict, so people started to avoid butter, eggs, steaks,
bacon and other foods high in cholesterol. The thing is, the science wasn't settled,
it was just popular There's more nuance to this story, and the scientific community protested
the decision. The American Egg Board made a campaign so people would keep eating eggs,
and over the next 50 years, the science slowly pushed people back from the edge.
Researchers told people again and again over the years that fat doesn't cause health problems
on its own. High Density Lipoproteins were discovered in the late 1920s, and Low Density
Lipoproteins in the late 70s, but cholesterol itself is created in your liver and helps
cells form protective membranes. PLUS, it's a building block for vitamin D!
As dietary science progressed, it's been shown that a low-carbohydrate diet is better than
a low-fat diet, but the public's mindset had been set. Nevermind that an epidemic of heart
disease which, in part, prompted this scramble for answers, was hitting the country, or that
the lead researcher only studied populations in the U.S., Japan, and Europe who were selected
because they would confirm the results the researcher wanted.
The thing is, if you lived through this period, you'd assume science kept flip-flopping! But
that's not the case, instead, the peer-reviewed science was consistent and the media and public
were simply sending mixed messages to each other. Now, new science has finally resulted
in the cholesterol guidelines being removed from the 2015 government guidelines. It took
a while, because science takes a while! Longitudinal nutrition studies can take decades to complete,
and have to be giant populations who are heavily scrutinized! This is opposed to cross-sectional
studies, which are a snapshot of a sample, still helpful, but very different. It takes
time to do good science, but we gotta do it.
With this in mind, I would like to say, we at DNews report what is happening in science
as best as we can, but let's be honest, we might make a video next year which says the
exact opposite thing of a video this year! Hopefully, we spot that and point out the
change, because science isn't set, more research is always needed.