YouSub
bending truth [cc]

en English

bending truth [cc] English subtitles

0 downloads · 498 lines · added Feb 14, 2016

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

People who make it out of groups like exploitative religious and pseudoscientific organisations
are often faced with distortions from two directions.
When they attempt to convey their experiences of manipulation to members of their former group
their words are magically transformed into 'I'm mad, evil and weak'.
But when they share their story with non-members as a cautionary tale
their words are often magically transformed into 'I'm gullible, asinine and spineless'.
After a while, the apostates realise they're in the noonesland of the unheard.
And it begins to become clear why these groups continue to thrive —
groups with a talent for bending truth,
preaching love while denouncing non-members as a subhuman underclass;
claiming to champion peace, while committing acts of barbarism;
pontificating about family values while tearing up countless homes;
promising freedom and enlightenment while enforcing ignorance and exercising total control
I want to explore some of the mechanics of manipulative groups,
dispatching some of the stereotypes about the people who get recruited by them,
and reflecting on preventive measures we might take to avoid recruitment.
But if there's just one thing I really want to do in this video,
it's to communicate the importance of acknowledging a simple but profound fact:
we can be manipulated
At a press conference on manipulative groups
Ian reveals he lost tens of thousands of dollars
When he was recruited by a group who proposed that
clusters of alien spirits are attached to all humans, keeping us from a full potential.
Ian tells us how he and the other group members paid through the nose — and every other orifice —
for a special kind of counselling which they were told would rid them of these spirits.
They were told that once these spirits were gone, they would be the primary causal agents of their lives
with skills such as telekinesis, total recall and mastery over illness.
No evidence was given for any of this.
The alien story was the unsubstantiated revelation claim of the group's founder
and no records have ever been produced of a single person
gaining any of the special powers or knowledge described.
What do we think of Ian?
Does he lack intelligence?
No. His intelligence is above average.
He's a highly creative, resourceful man — that's why the group considered him such a juicy prospect.
Is he a bit credulous — quick to accept whatever he's told?
No. In fact, by default, he's a cautious skeptical fellow.
Is he driven by narcissism, desiring supremacy over others?
No. He's always been compelled by deeply humanitarian instincts.
Of course there are folks out there who are ....
gullible, obtuse, submissive, power-hungry, escapist, lazy.
But it's a huge mistake to assume that
successful recruitment into manipulative groups depends on the presence of these kinds of traits.
And while we're hunting for them in Ian's case, we're missing six crucial words:
'he was recruited by a group'.
He was subjected to a process.
The idea of alien spirit clusters wasn't presented to him in the bald way he presented it to us.
Ian was carefully steered through a sequence of experiences
so that by the time the alien spirits concept was mentioned
a range of key psychological elements had been established
to ease its entry and help insulate it from criticism.
Later on, I'll be looking at how this was done.
Just as we can become distracted by the red herring of personality deficiencies
we can become misled by the notion of predisposing circumstance.
Some psychologists have generated lists of situational factors
that can leave us vulnerable to manipulative groups.
Factors like 'weak family bonds' or 'recent bereavement'.
Problem is, when we don't find ourselves reflected in those items,
we can be left with the impression we're not vulnerable.
When we see an item like 'weak family bonds'
we might satisfy ourselves that we not risk
because we have strong family bonds.
But strong family bonds can put people at risk too.
Many people are recruited by relative.
And if your whole family's been indoctrinated,
you could be born into a manipulative group.
In these cases, even if you wake up and smell the Kool Aid
strong family bonds might keep you feeling trapped inside the group
under the threat of disconnection from your family.
Members of manipulative groups are a diverse population
and it serves us well to think creatively
about how these groups might hook us in.
Some of us go through life convinced we possess an almost clinical objectivity —
that, barring deliberate deceptions or the odd quirky optical illusion,
we generally perceived reality as it actually is; and that we make decisions on a firmly rational basis.
For over a century, social psychologists have been ripping that fantasy apart,
conducting experiments that elicit the most bizarre, counterintuitive human responses
and exposing a gamut of distinct biases
each of which distorts our perception in its own specific way.
A landmark concept in social psychology emerged in the 1950s
that provided a framework on which to untangle all kinds of paradoxical human behaviour.
Leon Festinger's theory of cognitive dissonance.
It also described arguably the biggest implement in the toolboxes of manipulative groups
who not only rely on it to keep existing members under their influence
but also actively exploit it to recruit new members.
Festinger and his colleagues proposed that we seek consistency within our cognitions —
our thoughts, emotions, memories, perceptions —
and that when we discover an inconsistency we experience a psychological discomfort
that motivates us to try and reduce that conflict.
So, what does dissonance look like in action?
Say we've been told to believe all members of group A evil.
One day, a friend we've always known to be a good person reveals she's a member of group A.
This arouses dissonance because our experience contradicts our belief.
We can reduce this dissonance in a number of ways.
If we're not hugely invested in the belief, we might opt for method one:
simply adjust our belief.
We might, for instance, change it to: 'not all members of group A are evil'.
If we're equally invested in the belief and the friendship
we might try to preserve both using method two: denial.
We might refuse to believe our friend is a true member of group A,
granting her special exemption because she's just not like those other folks.
If we're more invested in the belief than the friendship, we might go for method three:
select confirming information.
Here, we cherry-pick information consistent with our belief and ignore information that contradicts it.
Any flaws in our friend's behaviour or attitudes can be turned against her
while her goodness is ignored.
Festinger and his colleagues noted that when we experience dissonance
we'll tend to avoid information or situations that threaten further dissonance.
For instance, if we've denied that our friend is a member of group A,
we'll want to avoid the subject in future conversations.
Or, if we've used selective information to cast our friend as evil,
we might quickly break off contact to avoid giving her the chance to reason with us.
But sometimes our response to dissonance is so horrendously distorted
that it makes us almost invulnerable to further dissonance,
reducing our need for avoidance.
For example, say we look for evidence that our friend's evil, but can't find any?
What if — time after time — we're confronted with good?
How can we possibly preserve a belief that all members of group A are evil now?
Well, all is not as bleak as it seems.
We have method four: repackaging.
Believing that no member of group A could possibly be good
We could repackage our experience of our friend's goodness as something it's not.
We might tell ourselves she was only pretending to be good — it was all an act, a deception.
And isn't that the most insidious evil of all?
The evil that disguises itself as good?
The wolf in sheep's clothing?
We've now put our friend in a no-win position.
Even her goodness has now become evidence of her evil.
Now we don't even have to avoid her.
Anything she does — good or bad — confirms our belief.
Later on, I'll be looking at how manipulative groups explicitly employ these kinds of extreme contortions
to put their critics in a no-win position
and keep their members under psychological lockdown.
Various experiments have shown how dissonance can be actively exploited to induce positive responses.
In a 1959 paper
Aronson and Mills investigated the role of initiation procedures in attitudes toward groups.
They advertised for female subjects to join a group discussing the psychology of sex.
But before being accepted, subjects were told they had to pass an embarrassment test.
There were three experimental conditions.
Subjects in the 'severe initiation' condition
read out loud to the experimenter a list of words considered obscene
as well as sexually explicit passages.
Subjects in the 'mild initiation' condition read out loud a list of sexual but non-obscene terms.
Subjects in the 'no initiation' condition weren't screened.
Each subject then listened to the same pre-recorded discussion, deliberately designed to be boring.
They then rated their perceptions of the group.
Intuitively, one might think the more severe the initiation
the more the discussion's dreariness would be accentuated.
But the reverse was true.
Subjects from the 'severe' condition showed the strongest liking for the group,
rating it as significantly more attractive compared with the ratings of the other groups.
Aronson and Mills explained this counter-intuitive finding in terms of dissonance between two cognitions:
subjects in the 'severe' condition had gone through a difficult experience to join the group,
but the group wasn't worthwhile.
When we invest time, effort, money, emotion, in an enterprise
we want to believe our investment isn't wasted.
So we repackage useless enterprises as useful.
This result, supported by other studies,
demonstrates how worthless groups can be made to appear worthwhile.
A decade later, Knox and Inkster showed just how quickly actions can induce attitudes.
At a racetrack, 69 bettors were asked by one experimenter, just prior to betting
to rate the chances of their horse winning.
72 bettors were asked by a second experimenter, just after placing their bets.
Using a 7-point scale, on average, pre-bettors rated their chances 'fair'.
Post-bettors rated their chances 'good'.
One bettor, who'd given a rating to the pre-bet experimenter and placed his bet
then spotted the post-bet experimenter and asked if the two were working together.
He then enquired if he could now change his rating from 'fair' to 'excellent'.
Studies like this show the important role behaviour plays in dissonance.
In fact, when we're looking at the components of dissonance
we could divide them into three broad classes: behaviour, emotions and thoughts.
Pull hard enough on one and, in our drive for consistency, the others will follow
When we behave as if we're committed, our thoughts and emotions often fall in line.
But how do we become so heavily invested in an idea
that we find ourselves twisting concepts into their opposites —
bending 'good' into 'evil', 'love' into 'hate' — just to preserve that idea?
While cognitive dissonance studies tend to focus on the conflict between two ideas
those two ideas don't of course exist in isolation.
Networks of reinforcing ideas often lie behind them.
For instance, regarding our hypothetical belief that group A is evil
maybe our entire community has always vehemently condemned group A.
We might have behaved hatefully toward some members of group A ourselves in the past
based solely on this prejudice.
We might also have seen group A sympathisers being attacked and ostracised.
If it turns out group A isn't evil, we have some tough realities to face.
First, we have to admit our entire community is wrong.
This could tap into some hefty issues around trust, loyalty and credibility.
Second, we'll have to admit our own hateful behaviour was unjustified.
This could have big implications for our self-image.
Third, we now face being attacked and ostracised if we defend groups A
which taps into our ideas of safety and security.
These tough realities might feel intensely threatening to us.
But the threat goes away if we can find some way of preserving our belief that group A is evil.
So it is that we might find ourselves turning on our friend just to preserve a false belief.
And of course this might in itself make it even harder to admit our mistake in the future
because adding to all the other tough realities
we'll now have to admit we betrayed a good friend.
Our minds are not objective, logical machines.
Our minds of vast networks of ideas, striving not necessarily for truth
but for internal consistency.
In view of this, it's plain to see why childhood is by far the most preferred period
for indoctrination into manipulative groups.
Parents and guardians can get in there right at the start
and insert any unsubstantiated concept they like
into the child's basic initial framework without resistance.
Being implanted so early
they stand a good chance of becoming core beliefs
with rich networks of ideas reinforcing them including strong associations of identity of many levels —
individual, family, culture, perhaps nationality.
If the unsubstantiated concept is later challenged, threatening tremors could be felt in all of these areas.
Indoctrinating adults who've already developed an advanced cognitive network isn't so straightforward.
Manipulative groups often have to insert their unsubstantiated ideas
into a distinctly inhospitable environment.
And it's no coincidence that in order to achieve that goal
some groups will try to mimic those childhood conditions by infantilising adults.
When I was a christian we were repeatedly told that we needed to be like children —
trusting and dependent on Yahweh
which in the total absence of any evidence of Yahweh
translates to: 'trusting and dependent on the humans who claim to represent Yahweh'.
And there was a nice little threat thrown in there.
If you didn't become like children, you'd never get into heaven.
In a similar vein we were told: 'Lean not on your own understanding'.
'Do not be wise in your own eyes'.
The message in all these commands couldn't be clearer.
Wherever your ideas conflict with those of the group, it's your ideas that need to change.
Folks who submit to these commands can now have vast amounts of their cognitive network rewritten
without substantial resistance — just like childhood.
Of course, adult recruits are more of a bonus than a necessity for the major world religions
who are guaranteed a steady influx of child recruits
As long as the abuse of childhood religious indoctrination continues.
Other groups who are more reliant on adult recruits
often have to manipulate cognitive dissonance in more subtle ways.
Let's go back to Ian and see how he gets recruited
by a group claiming clusters of alien spirits are attached to us all
keeping us from a full potential.
Ian is approached on the street by a woman with a personality questionnaire.
He agrees to accompany her inside the official promises behind her
where he spends half an hour completing it.
His results show him to be unstable, depressed, nervous and overly critical.
These conflict with his self-image.
But the woman talks with him for a further half hour about his life — his frustrations, his disappointments —
and draws tentative connections with his results.
She says her group runs courses that can help him become a more effective person.
Ian's natural caution stops him from signing up for a course
but he agrees to buy a cheap book.
He now experiences his first cognitive dissonance in the group's favour.
He has two conflicting cognitions: one, that he's not interested;
but two, that he's just invested an hour of his time and bought a book.
Dissonance leads him to adjust his first cognition and rationalise that he is interested.
Going home, he dips into the book and reflects on the idea of becoming a more effective person.
The questionnaire results begin to play on his mind.
Despite himself, he begins to select confirming information
finding memories that match the results.
Deciding he has nothing to lose by giving it a go, he returns
and signs up for a course on communication.
Ian is now locked into a commitment cycle.
The more time and money he invests, the more he becomes convinced it's worthwhile
The easier he's persuaded to invest more time and money in further courses.
The courses include odd activities like sitting in silence, staring at another member
or endlessly picking up the same object.
These meaningless tasks confuse Ian
And induce trance states and hallucinations
increasing his susceptibility to direction.
At the end of each course Ian has to write up and read out loud to the group
how the course helped him.
This forces him not only to find meaning in the meaningless tasks
but to declare it publicly.
Declaring benefits he doesn't really feel creates dissonance
which Ian reduces by rationalising that he does feel benefits.
His dissonance is further reduced in two ways.
First, Ian's speech receives huge praise and applause from other members
validating his words and building on his feelings of acceptance and loyalty to the group.
Second, the testimony of other members further justifies the idea that the tasks have meaning.
Other activities train Ian not to react to provocation.
For instance, when being goaded with insults and jokes by other members.
Ian learns to disconnect from confrontation.
He rationalises that this training is helping him focus.
It'll soon be put to other uses.
Ian's told of the group's interest in the betterment of humankind.
Their aim is 'total freedom for everyone on the planet'.
This resonates powerfully with his own humanitarian concerns.
But he's told about critics who want to sabotage this important work,
spreading lies and alienating members.
The group encourages Ian to avoid mainstream media for this reason.
He's always been against censorship.
But censorship has now been repackaged as a sensible precaution against destructive critics.
Thee group now controls all information about the group.
When later confronted by critics in person
Ian automatically disconnects from them, as he's been trained to do
blocking out the very folks who could help him.
In everyday life, Ian feels better, sharper, more confident
more effective.
But it's an illusion.
With the group's courses pitched at kindergarten levels, in developmental terms, far from being stretched
Ian's been slowly regressing.
After completing the basic courses
Ian's processed straight into the next level.
A strange over-ritualised kind of counseling is introduced
using lie-detector like technology
to gauge his emotional reaction as he repeatedly confronts difficult memories.
The aim is to nullify all emotional reaction to past traumas
until it no longer registers on the apparatus.
These counselling sessions are expensive.
Sometimes very tiring. But he frequently emerges feeling lighter.
The sessions take him further and further into the past
until he's not quite sure if he's dealing with real memories.
Ian visits his parents. He talks about the group.
His father is concerned about the money Ian's getting through
and does an internet search on the group.
He's disturbed at what he reads
and asked Ian to take a look
but Ian declines, saying it's all lies.
When he tells the group about his parents' reaction.
Ian finds himself being interviewed at length
with concerns expressed about how their influence could seriously damage his progress.
At the end of an exhausting session
Ian agrees to only discuss superficial subjects with his parents.
He takes the issue to counselling to nullify his emotional reaction.
The groups' noble aim of total freedom for everyone on the planet has been repackaged.
'Total freedom' now means: 'fr
…

Need subtitles from another video?