Advertisement
English transcript
This episode of DNews is presented by Kay Jewelers. Every kiss begins with Kay.
We’d love to believe our partner is perfect, and we fell for them because they’re the
one, but in reality, it’s all about circumstance.
Forming human or animal pair-bonds is a complicated thing. There so many different parts, priorities,
and social systems - it’s shocking we ever pair up at all. While the obvious things,
like looks and personality are emphasized by magazines and love stories, there are a
number of other scientific studies looking at how we pick our partners.
Framing effect is a social communication theory which examines how we look at the world around
us, the FRAMES we put around things. For example, if you buy meat, they sell it as 80-percent
fat FREE -- which means it's still 20-percent fat, but you don't think about that, because
they FRAMED it in a more positive way. WHOLE milk sounds super thick in comparison to 2
percent, but whole is only 3.5 percent. It's all about the framing, and we do this when
we're looking for partners too.
Often, we instinctively stumble into the right way to frame an idea. For example, if a woman
wants a man to find her attractive, she might wear her favorite red shirt. A study in the
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology from 2008 found the color of our clothing
changes the perception of a possible partner. We're not talking the cut or how flattering
the clothing is, simply the color. It's commonly understood that red is the love color, and
this research supports that idea. Volunteers were shown a variety of pictures of women,
the color of the backgrounds, photo borders and even the shirt of the subject was digitally
altered to red or other colors. The red consistently increased ratings of attractiveness for men,
but not for women. The color didn't change estimations of kindness, intelligence or likeability;
only attractiveness.
Another new study in Evolution and Human Behavior explores positive versus negative framing.
Positive framing is saying 80-percent fat free, because that's what you WANT, while
negative framing would be 20-percent fat -- because you're focusing on the thing to avoid. This
new research found the framing effect for mating is even more pronounced for women than
men -- and women are on the lookout for the NEGATIVE frame. They presented one of two
frames to their participants: either seven out of ten know this person is kind, OR three
out of ten know this person is not kind. One or the other, not both. Note that the information
is EXACTLY the same, three to seven; it's just presented differently. According to their
results, women focused on the three, not the seven and were far less likely to say they'd
date someone who was presented in the negative frame!
The researchers believe it has to do with evolutionary focus on rearing offspring. According
to them, choosing a poor provider or unloving father would have serious consequences. I
felt a little skeezed by this research, so I dug a bit further. Turns out, a study in
Psychological Science says societal frames matter too. Researchers looked at 31 nations,
and how each society framed the sexes, either more equal, or less equal; and how that affected
partner selection. In gender-unequal societies, people were more likely to pick a mate using
more traditional evolutionary tropes. Conversely, the more gender-equal the societal frame was,
the less likely men and women were to choose a partner along the lines of evolutionary
psychology. More equality means men and women weren't ONLY looking for a strong provider
in a man and ability to birth children -- of course, we can't escape our evolution entirely.
Partners just didn't value those traits as highly. And, of course, red still wins. Keep
wearing red.
What do you think of all this? Do you pay attention to how you're framing yourself?
Maybe
you should!
We’d love to believe our partner is perfect, and we fell for them because they’re the
one, but in reality, it’s all about circumstance.
Forming human or animal pair-bonds is a complicated thing. There so many different parts, priorities,
and social systems - it’s shocking we ever pair up at all. While the obvious things,
like looks and personality are emphasized by magazines and love stories, there are a
number of other scientific studies looking at how we pick our partners.
Framing effect is a social communication theory which examines how we look at the world around
us, the FRAMES we put around things. For example, if you buy meat, they sell it as 80-percent
fat FREE -- which means it's still 20-percent fat, but you don't think about that, because
they FRAMED it in a more positive way. WHOLE milk sounds super thick in comparison to 2
percent, but whole is only 3.5 percent. It's all about the framing, and we do this when
we're looking for partners too.
Often, we instinctively stumble into the right way to frame an idea. For example, if a woman
wants a man to find her attractive, she might wear her favorite red shirt. A study in the
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology from 2008 found the color of our clothing
changes the perception of a possible partner. We're not talking the cut or how flattering
the clothing is, simply the color. It's commonly understood that red is the love color, and
this research supports that idea. Volunteers were shown a variety of pictures of women,
the color of the backgrounds, photo borders and even the shirt of the subject was digitally
altered to red or other colors. The red consistently increased ratings of attractiveness for men,
but not for women. The color didn't change estimations of kindness, intelligence or likeability;
only attractiveness.
Another new study in Evolution and Human Behavior explores positive versus negative framing.
Positive framing is saying 80-percent fat free, because that's what you WANT, while
negative framing would be 20-percent fat -- because you're focusing on the thing to avoid. This
new research found the framing effect for mating is even more pronounced for women than
men -- and women are on the lookout for the NEGATIVE frame. They presented one of two
frames to their participants: either seven out of ten know this person is kind, OR three
out of ten know this person is not kind. One or the other, not both. Note that the information
is EXACTLY the same, three to seven; it's just presented differently. According to their
results, women focused on the three, not the seven and were far less likely to say they'd
date someone who was presented in the negative frame!
The researchers believe it has to do with evolutionary focus on rearing offspring. According
to them, choosing a poor provider or unloving father would have serious consequences. I
felt a little skeezed by this research, so I dug a bit further. Turns out, a study in
Psychological Science says societal frames matter too. Researchers looked at 31 nations,
and how each society framed the sexes, either more equal, or less equal; and how that affected
partner selection. In gender-unequal societies, people were more likely to pick a mate using
more traditional evolutionary tropes. Conversely, the more gender-equal the societal frame was,
the less likely men and women were to choose a partner along the lines of evolutionary
psychology. More equality means men and women weren't ONLY looking for a strong provider
in a man and ability to birth children -- of course, we can't escape our evolution entirely.
Partners just didn't value those traits as highly. And, of course, red still wins. Keep
wearing red.
What do you think of all this? Do you pay attention to how you're framing yourself?
Maybe
you should!